Catholic FAQ


Latest Threads
newest posts



Go Back   Catholic Answers Forums > Forums > Non-Catholic Religions
 

Welcome to Catholic Answers Forums, the largest Catholic Community on the Web.

Here you can join over 400,000 members from around the world discussing all things Catholic. Membership is open to all, Catholic and non-Catholic alike, who seek the Truth with Charity.

To gain full access, you must register for a FREE account. Registered members are able to:
  • Submit questions about the faith to experts from Catholic Answers
  • Participate in all forum discussions
  • Communicate privately with Catholics from around the world
  • Plus join a prayer group, read with the Book Club, and much more.
Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. So join our community today!

Have a question about registration or your account log-in? Just contact our Support Hotline.

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Search Thread Display
  #1  
Old Dec 13, '04, 10:26 am
Chris-WA Chris-WA is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: June 20, 2004
Posts: 845
Default LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

I tried a similar thread a little while ago but got no LDS response. There are a couple of more LDS posting now so I want to pose this question to them. I would like to limit this discussion to the Great Apostacy issue between Mormons and Catholics. If you want to go outside of this, please start another thread.

I would like to know why LDS believe in the Great Apostacy--why, when, how it happened, etc.
  #2  
Old Dec 13, '04, 10:33 am
Tmaque Tmaque is offline
Book Club Member
 
Join Date: May 21, 2004
Posts: 1,014
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

This is right from www.lds.org:

"After the Apostles and many righteous Church members were killed and other members departed from the truth, the Lord took the priesthood authority and His Church from the earth. Without Godís priesthood authority, the Church no longer functioned as Christ had established it. The ordinances were changed and many plain and simple truths were lost. While many good people and some truth remained, the original Church was lost."
__________________
God bless you,

T Shaffer
Tiber Swim Team - Class of 03
  #3  
Old Dec 13, '04, 12:07 pm
Alisha Alisha is offline
New Member
 
Join Date: October 30, 2004
Posts: 7
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tmaque
This is right from www.lds.org:

"After the Apostles and many righteous Church members were killed and other members departed from the truth, the Lord took the priesthood authority and His Church from the earth. Without Godís priesthood authority, the Church no longer functioned as Christ had established it. The ordinances were changed and many plain and simple truths were lost. While many good people and some truth remained, the original Church was lost."
How could priesthood authority be taken from the earth with the apostle John still alive? "You are a priest FOREVER in the order of Melchizedek" the Bible says, and John held (holds) the Melchizedek priesthood, did (does) he not? I'm under the impression that LDS believe that the apostle John is still alive and ministering on this earth. Well, if John never died, and a holder of the Melcheizedek priesthood is a priest forever, how did priesthood authority get taken from the earth?

And how could the Church be lost when Christ promised that "the gates of hell shall not prevail against it"?

Alisha
  #4  
Old Dec 13, '04, 12:11 pm
tkdnick tkdnick is offline
Prayer Warrior
 
Join Date: September 7, 2004
Posts: 6,745
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alisha
And how could the Church be lost when Christ promised that "the gates of hell shall not prevail against it"?
From an LDS member (NOT MY BELIEF): The gates of hell did not prevail because God took the keys/authority away.
__________________
I do believe, help my unbelief! - Mark 9:24
  #5  
Old Dec 13, '04, 2:21 pm
catsrus catsrus is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: October 7, 2004
Posts: 3,335
Religion: Roman Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Okayyyy...and where is the DOCUMENTATION that the keys and authority were taken away by God?

LDS, please respond.
  #6  
Old Dec 13, '04, 5:59 pm
Aris's Avatar
Aris Aris is offline
Junior Member
Prayer Warrior
 
Join Date: May 25, 2004
Posts: 410
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

The major flaw of LDS and other churches teaching that the original church apostasized is logic. They have to teach this doctrine for them to be recognized as credible and authoritative.

However, if they believe that it was Jesus Christ that saved the world and that Christ was the perfect man, then this theory does not hold. How can they say He was perfect when he failed miserably in founding a church?
  #7  
Old Dec 13, '04, 7:51 pm
cestusdei cestusdei is offline
 
Join Date: July 17, 2004
Posts: 3,055
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

I usually ask them to give me the specific date of the apostacy, what engendered it, and who was the main protaganist. I ask for specific historical answers. I have yet to get one.
  #8  
Old Dec 13, '04, 7:57 pm
PaulDupre PaulDupre is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: May 19, 2004
Posts: 4,738
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aris
However, if they believe that it was Jesus Christ that saved the world and that Christ was the perfect man, then this theory does not hold. How can they say He was perfect when he failed miserably in founding a church?
The LDS believe that Jesus failed twice - once with the Church in the Old World and again with the Church in the Americas as recounted in the Book of Mormon. According to the LDS, both Churches fell into total apostacy within a generation, making the Mormon Jesus a two-time loser.

But never fear. Joseph Smith claimed that he was able to do what Jesus could not:

Quote:
"I am the only man that has ever been able to keep a whole church together since the days of Adam...Neither Paul, John, Peter, nor Jesus ever did it. I boast that no man ever did such a work as I. The followers of Jesus ran away from Him; but the Latter-day Saints never ran away from me yet." (History of the Church, Vol. 6:408-9)
God bless you,
Paul
  #9  
Old Dec 13, '04, 11:29 pm
boppysbud boppysbud is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: June 24, 2004
Posts: 434
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

I don't think it is likely that you will ever get an answer from a member of the LDS church to your question.

This is just something that is assumed on thier part to be true (like sola scriptura is accepted by Evangelicals) without deeply looking into the truth or proof for it.

BTW, I have asked Mormons just what exactly was "Restored" instead of invented in the 19th century by Joseph Smith and Brigham Young, and where there is proof for these teachings to have existed prior, in order to be "restored".

I have gotten silence to that question as well.
  #10  
Old Dec 14, '04, 2:07 am
mormon fool mormon fool is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: December 6, 2004
Posts: 651
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris-WA
I would like to know why LDS believe in the Great Apostacy--why, when, how it happened, etc.
I never was very good at self-discipline.

So here goes my top 10 reasons for believing in the apostasy:

1. God said so (as reported by Joseph Smith).
2. Hugh Nibley said so in his "40 variations on an unpopular theme", "The World and the Prophets", and other works.
3. Barry Bickmore said so in his book on "Restoring the Ancient Church", and debates with Steve Clifford.
4. James Talmage said so in his book " The Great Apostasy".
5. I interpret the scriptures as containing a history of apostasy/restoration cycles.
6. I interpret the Bible as predicting an apostasy: 2 Thes. 2 ish, etc., etc. and ignore the counter proof-texts.
7. The fruits of an apostasy are evident in every church besides (insert church title here).
8. I am un-impressed with all the counter-arguments (so-far).
9. I selectively use quotes of apostolic fathers and company to support my position .
10. My philosophy about God is that He is powerful enough to grant his children free (moral) agency and that they are free* to cafeteria style reject some of His gospel. And at the same time He is merciful enough not to condemn any one who does not have an opportunity to accept His whole gospel.

I will have to get to how, when, and (more of) why it happened later. Some nice questions and observations have been made that I will have to get to later. If I write too much about the apostasy, will I get in trouble with the moderators? I am sure you all can refute me, but I don't want to be disrespectful. I listed the references in answer above if anyone really wants to see an articulate presentation.

*free to decide what they will do but not free to decide the consequences.
  #11  
Old Dec 14, '04, 2:14 am
Aris's Avatar
Aris Aris is offline
Junior Member
Prayer Warrior
 
Join Date: May 25, 2004
Posts: 410
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by PaulDupre
The LDS believe that Jesus failed twice - once with the Church in the Old World and again with the Church in the Americas as recounted in the Book of Mormon. According to the LDS, both Churches fell into total apostacy within a generation, making the Mormon Jesus a two-time loser.

But never fear. Joseph Smith claimed that he was able to do what Jesus could not:



God bless you,
Paul
Thanks, Paul. I have not heard this boast before. It just affirms their status as the Anti-Christ.
  #12  
Old Dec 14, '04, 3:56 am
Tmaque Tmaque is offline
Book Club Member
 
Join Date: May 21, 2004
Posts: 1,014
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by mormon fool
I never was very good at self-discipline.

So here goes my top 10 reasons for believing in the apostasy:

1. God said so (as reported by Joseph Smith).
2. Hugh Nibley said so in his "40 variations on an unpopular theme", "The World and the Prophets", and other works.
3. Barry Bickmore said so in his book on "Restoring the Ancient Church", and debates with Steve Clifford.
4. James Talmage said so in his book " The Great Apostasy".
5. I interpret the scriptures as containing a history of apostasy/restoration cycles.
6. I interpret the Bible as predicting an apostasy: 2 Thes. 2 ish, etc., etc. and ignore the counter proof-texts.
7. The fruits of an apostasy are evident in every church besides (insert church title here).
8. I am un-impressed with all the counter-arguments (so-far).
9. I selectively use quotes of apostolic fathers and company to support my position .
10. My philosophy about God is that He is powerful enough to grant his children free (moral) agency and that they are free* to cafeteria style reject some of His gospel. And at the same time He is merciful enough not to condemn any one who does not have an opportunity to accept His whole gospel.
Quite a tongue in cheek response ...I wonder how many will realize that.

I'm curious Mormon Fool, does it disturb you in away that there have been many doctrinal changes in your church? Looking simply at the evidence there have been many more doctrinal changes in LDS theology in just 174 years than there has been in Catholic theology in almost 2000 years. We know what the first century christians believed, taught and practiced. We know what sacraments (ordinances to you) they had, we know how they conducted themselves. I would think it difficult to claim that the changes were due to continuing revelation when God hasn't used it in the manner the LDS church claims......ever...until now? It's an entirely new phenomenon then. It doesn't add up.

Anyway, what I'm saying is that the church Joseph Smith restored doesn't much look like the LDS church that exists today. There are literally dozens and dozens of break offs. The doctrines and practices have changed....drastically. In fact, it's fair to say it's quite a mess, mass confusion actually, with all the different groups believing different things and claiming their own authority and revelation. A person that believes in the restoration could justifiably claim that the restored Gospel is not here in it's original form and God's restored church is in a state of total apostasy. In fact, I know many people who believe that very thing. I'm related to some fundamentalist LDS. What would be your rebuttal to their claim?

You yourself said in point #5 "I interpret the scriptures as containing a history of apostasy/restoration cycles." Maybe that cycle continues today. If I believed in the restoration I would have to come to that very conclusion.
__________________
God bless you,

T Shaffer
Tiber Swim Team - Class of 03
  #13  
Old Dec 14, '04, 4:14 am
Tmaque Tmaque is offline
Book Club Member
 
Join Date: May 21, 2004
Posts: 1,014
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aris
Thanks, Paul. I have not heard this boast before. It just affirms their status as the Anti-Christ.
Aris, why would you say something like that? You should be ashamed of yourself. Mormons are no different than you or I. We believe differently on a few issues, but that's where our differences end. Catholics don't have the market cornered on kindness, charity, hope, hard work, love, devotion, prayer, etc. In fact, we could learn from the Mormons in many respects. Particularly in the way we conduct our day to day lives. I'm PROUD of my LDS heritage. My LDS upbringing has served me well in life. You can question the validity of a person's beliefs but please don't question their motives! Most Mormons I know want more than anything to simply do what's right. How could you say something so hateful and mean? That was a very un-Catholic and un-Christian thing to say. Shame on you. You should apologize.
__________________
God bless you,

T Shaffer
Tiber Swim Team - Class of 03
  #14  
Old Dec 14, '04, 8:16 am
tkdnick tkdnick is offline
Prayer Warrior
 
Join Date: September 7, 2004
Posts: 6,745
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tmaque
Quite a tongue in cheek response ...I wonder how many will realize that.
So someone else noticed that it might be somewhat joking. I was looking at some of the answers wondering "is this really serious??"
__________________
I do believe, help my unbelief! - Mark 9:24
  #15  
Old Dec 14, '04, 9:24 am
Chris-WA Chris-WA is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: June 20, 2004
Posts: 845
Default Re: LDS--Why do you believe in the Great Apostacy?

Quote:
Originally Posted by mormon fool
I never was very good at self-discipline.

So here goes my top 10 reasons for believing in the apostasy:

1. God said so (as reported by Joseph Smith).
2. Hugh Nibley said so in his "40 variations on an unpopular theme", "The World and the Prophets", and other works.
3. Barry Bickmore said so in his book on "Restoring the Ancient Church", and debates with Steve Clifford.
4. James Talmage said so in his book " The Great Apostasy".
5. I interpret the scriptures as containing a history of apostasy/restoration cycles.
6. I interpret the Bible as predicting an apostasy: 2 Thes. 2 ish, etc., etc. and ignore the counter proof-texts.
7. The fruits of an apostasy are evident in every church besides (insert church title here).
8. I am un-impressed with all the counter-arguments (so-far).
9. I selectively use quotes of apostolic fathers and company to support my position .
10. My philosophy about God is that He is powerful enough to grant his children free (moral) agency and that they are free* to cafeteria style reject some of His gospel. And at the same time He is merciful enough not to condemn any one who does not have an opportunity to accept His whole gospel.

I will have to get to how, when, and (more of) why it happened later. Some nice questions and observations have been made that I will have to get to later. If I write too much about the apostasy, will I get in trouble with the moderators? I am sure you all can refute me, but I don't want to be disrespectful. I listed the references in answer above if anyone really wants to see an articulate presentation.

*free to decide what they will do but not free to decide the consequences.
Not sure how to take this post since part of it seems to be a joke. Let me point out a few things though. Your first 4 reasons are based on third-person perspectives some 1800-2000 years after the fact. I would suggest that there is enough contained within the Bible and early church history to keep the discussion focussed there. If there was an apostacy, it should be evident from scripture and early church history. I don't think God would let us go on for 1800 years in total apostacy and then tell us about it later.

For #5, I think what you're talking about is called dispensationalism, in which one looks at salvation history as a series of failed attempts of the church to faithfully live out the gospel. Whereas we Catholics look at salvation history as a gradual preparation for the coming of Christ and the establishment and growth of his church. For us, the bible contains many stories that are part of one continuous story.

For #6, I think if you reread all these verses in context, you will never find the prediction of a total apostacy. Of course, we also believe that apostacy occurred from the very beginning, but we have no indication that it forced the removal of authority from the earth. Christ tells us that the wheat and the chaff will exist together until the very end, but no one ever says that the church will disappear from the earth. I challenge you to find one verse that says this.

For #9, if it's not just a joke, there is no way anyone can make a credible argument from the church fathers that there was a total apostacy. I think you're referring to the online debate between Barry Bickmore and Thomas Smith. Mr. Bickmore does just what you mentioned--he takes selective quotes from church fathers and uses them to fit his argument. That's the problem with taking things out of context. If you're going to use quotes from the church fathers as proof in an argument, you can't ignore the other 99% of their writing as if it didn't exist. For goodness sakes, if any of the church fathers believed in a total apostacy, they wouldn't have continued to fight for the church.

And no, you won't get in trouble if you write about the apostacy. That's what this forum is all about.

Here's an article written back a Cathlolic on this issue. Give it a read and let us know what you think.

http://www.ewtn.com/library/ANSWERS/MORMON2.HTM
Closed Thread

Go Back   Catholic Answers Forums > Forums > Non-Catholic Religions

Bookmarks

Thread Tools Search Thread
Search Thread:

Advanced Search
Display

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump



Prayer Intentions

Most Active Groups
8458Meet and talk,talk talk
Last by: GLam8833
5146CAF Prayer Warriors Support Group
Last by: mountee
4424Devotion to the Sorrowful Mother
Last by: DesertSister62
4037OCD/Scrupulosity Group
Last by: eschator83
3863SOLITUDE
Last by: beth40n2
3738Let's empty Purgatory
Last by: RJB
3322Petitions Before the Blessed Sacrament
Last by: Amiciel
3284Poems and Reflections
Last by: PathWalker
3224Catholic Vegetarians & Vegans
Last by: 4elise
3110For seniors and shut- ins
Last by: flower lady



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 6:24 am.

Home RSS Feeds - Home - Archive - Top

Copyright © 2004-2014, Catholic Answers.