Catholic FAQ


Latest Threads
newest posts



Go Back   Catholic Answers Forums > Forums > Apologetics > Philosophy
 

Welcome to Catholic Answers Forums, the largest Catholic Community on the Web.

Here you can join over 400,000 members from around the world discussing all things Catholic. Membership is open to all, Catholic and non-Catholic alike, who seek the Truth with Charity.

To gain full access, you must register for a FREE account. Registered members are able to:
  • Submit questions about the faith to experts from Catholic Answers
  • Participate in all forum discussions
  • Communicate privately with Catholics from around the world
  • Plus join a prayer group, read with the Book Club, and much more.
Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. So join our community today!

Have a question about registration or your account log-in? Just contact our Support Hotline.

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Search Thread Display
  #1  
Old Feb 25, '12, 7:40 am
empther's Avatar
empther empther is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 8, 2004
Posts: 2,349
Religion: Catholic loyal to the Pope, don't even try to change me!
Default Finite past proves God exists

The universe could not have existed through an infinite past. Therefore, God had to start it.

Did any event happen an infinitely long time ago? Obviously not.

Now the atheists will try to talk about "non-linear time" or "imaginary time" or some nonsense like that. What they can't do is say how this takes the place of the linear time we experience. In fact it's nonsense.

The atheists will try to say there was some other cause of the universe. But another cause would in fact be part of the universe. Perhaps before the Big Bang there was something else. What? We can't imagine. And before that there may have been something else. And so on. But we can't go back to infinity. At some point we must arrive at a time when there was absolutely no universe in whatever form we want to think of it.

Therefore, there had to be a God to start it all.


Notice that Aquinas's Summa Theologica,
after discussing the nature of theology and why it's worth studying,
BEGINS BY DISCUSSING GOD'S EXISTENCE.

http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/aqui...mma/sum005.htm

Later,
he discusses other subjects such as the nature of evil and all those things.

But the athesits jump over the question of God's existence and try to confuse you with tons and tons of deceiving verbiage about the other issues such as the existence of evil, and things like that that understandably bother people.

We should follow Aquinas's example. First determine if God exists. Then work out the later problems later.
  #2  
Old Feb 25, '12, 8:37 am
John Carlton John Carlton is offline
Junior Member
 
Join Date: September 5, 2010
Posts: 192
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

We can't ask the unbelievers to play by our rules, they won't do it. Just like we won't play by theirs. I understand your frustration, but people are always going to believe what they're going to. When I was an atheist I looked for all the problems of Christianity and refused to see what was right with it. I realise they aren't all like that, just the sorts of ones we attract. In my dealings with unbelievers I have found that pointing out the religious roots to the theories they appropriate will often make them pause. I agree with you, though, it is somewhat irritating when the unbeliever purposely obscures theology to slant a point or so ignorantly butcher it that it loses all meaning.
  #3  
Old Feb 25, '12, 8:39 am
Pfaffenhoffen Pfaffenhoffen is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: August 4, 2011
Posts: 4,043
Religion: Roman Catholic Church, Latin Rite
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by empther View Post
The universe could not have existed through an infinite past. Therefore, God had to start it.

Did any event happen an infinitely long time ago? Obviously not.

Now the atheists will try to talk about "non-linear time" or "imaginary time" or some nonsense like that. What they can't do is say how this takes the place of the linear time we experience. In fact it's nonsense.

The atheists will try to say there was some other cause of the universe. But another cause would in fact be part of the universe. Perhaps before the Big Bang there was something else. What? We can't imagine. And before that there may have been something else. And so on. But we can't go back to infinity. At some point we must arrive at a time when there was absolutely no universe in whatever form we want to think of it.

Therefore, there had to be a God to start it all.


Notice that Aquinas's Summa Theologica,
after discussing the nature of theology and why it's worth studying,
BEGINS BY DISCUSSING GOD'S EXISTENCE.

http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/aqui...mma/sum005.htm

Later,
he discusses other subjects such as the nature of evil and all those things.

But the athesits jump over the question of God's existence and try to confuse you with tons and tons of deceiving verbiage about the other issues such as the existence of evil, and things like that that understandably bother people.

We should follow Aquinas's example. First determine if God exists. Then work out the later problems later.


I have discussed that before and I accept this answer: "The universe could be infinite as long as it was created by God".

Nevertheless, I believe in a finite Universe, from the logic of the Universe: birth, life, death.
  #4  
Old Feb 25, '12, 11:15 am
Katholish's Avatar
Katholish Katholish is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: May 19, 2004
Posts: 1,015
Religion: Roman Rite Catholic
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by empther View Post
The universe could not have existed through an infinite past. Therefore, God had to start it.
St. Thomas thinks that is false, and I tend to agree. The universe could have had an infinite past. That there was a beginning of time is something revealed by Revelation, but not known through reason alone. When St. Thomas makes an argument proving God's eixstence through causality, it is important to understand that not all causes are temporal causes (i.e. not all causes occur within time).
__________________
Student of Systematic Theology at the Notre Dame Graduate School of Christendom College.

A good site to learn more about Catholic homeschooling:
Catholic Homeschooling
  #5  
Old Feb 25, '12, 5:39 pm
empther's Avatar
empther empther is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 8, 2004
Posts: 2,349
Religion: Catholic loyal to the Pope, don't even try to change me!
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
St. Thomas thinks that is false, and I tend to agree.
So far so good. I think. It's hard to know what you're saying.


Quote:
The universe could have had an infinite past.
It could not. I'm really surprised you said that. How could any event have happened an infinite time ago?

Quote:
That there was a beginning of time is something revealed by Revelation, but not known through reason alone.
Even Aristotle said you can't go back to infinity and he did not have Revelation.

Quote:
When St. Thomas makes an argument proving God's eixstence through causality, it is important to understand that not all causes are temporal causes (i.e. not all causes occur within time).
I think you mean effect, or cause and effect. Anyway, can you give an example of a cause and effect that does not occur within time?
  #6  
Old Feb 25, '12, 5:45 pm
empther's Avatar
empther empther is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 8, 2004
Posts: 2,349
Religion: Catholic loyal to the Pope, don't even try to change me!
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
I have discussed that before and I accept this answer: "The universe could be infinite as long as it was created by God".
Do you mean infinite in duration through time or infinite in size?
God could not create an infinite universe in either sense. This truth tells us that he did create the universe and he exists.
  #7  
Old Feb 25, '12, 5:48 pm
ASimon ASimon is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 29, 2011
Posts: 828
Religion: None
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by empther View Post
We should follow Aquinas's example. First determine if God exists. Then work out the later problems later.
Have we any idea of when it's scheduled to be later? These "problems" you speak of are, in fact, the whole ballgame, and I want to make sure I get good seats for when they get worked out.
  #8  
Old Feb 25, '12, 6:05 pm
Joe Kelley Joe Kelley is offline
Forum Elder
 
Join Date: June 24, 2004
Posts: 15,433
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by Katholish View Post
St. Thomas thinks that is false, and I tend to agree. The universe could have had an infinite past. That there was a beginning of time is something revealed by Revelation, but not known through reason alone. When St. Thomas makes an argument proving God's eixstence through causality, it is important to understand that not all causes are temporal causes (i.e. not all causes occur within time).
Science seems to have proven that the universe had a beginning in the Big Bang.

One must also consider that given sufficient time a system will pass through all possible states of change. Two of these states are 1. Perfection after which it no longer changes and 2. Annihilation after which it no longer exists. Given infinite time the universe would have reached one or the other long ago. Since it exists and is still changing, it must have experienced only a finite time.
__________________
I have set before you life and death, blessing and curse; therefore choose life, that you and your descendants may live,
  #9  
Old Feb 25, '12, 6:08 pm
empther's Avatar
empther empther is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 8, 2004
Posts: 2,349
Religion: Catholic loyal to the Pope, don't even try to change me!
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by empther
We should follow Aquinas's example. First determine if God exists. Then work out the later problems later.
Have we any idea of when it's scheduled to be later? These "problems" you speak of are, in fact, the whole ballgame, and I want to make sure I get good seats for when they get worked out.
How could a good God allow evil? Does God have omniscience? Omnipotence? Goodness?

First, you have to settle that God exists. Then you can work out these problems. Actually, Aquinas and other writers have already done it.

One of the primary strategities of atheists is to concentrate on one of these later problems, try to make you believe that nobody has the solution, ( although Aquinas does ! )
and therefore make you wonder if there's a God at all
since they haven't pointed to the point of this thread,
that an infinite past is impossible and God had to start the universe.

But they're not going to get away with that on this thread.
  #10  
Old Feb 25, '12, 6:13 pm
empther's Avatar
empther empther is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 8, 2004
Posts: 2,349
Religion: Catholic loyal to the Pope, don't even try to change me!
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Science seems to have proven that the universe had a beginning in the Big Bang.
I agree with you, Joe. I don't see why God would have created some universe before the Big Bang, since there would now be no trace of it.

However, the atheist might say there was something before the Big Bang, implying that there was some kind of universe through infinite time. I contend this is impossible and there had to be a point in time for the "Big Begin".
  #11  
Old Feb 25, '12, 6:19 pm
ASimon ASimon is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 29, 2011
Posts: 828
Religion: None
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by empther View Post
Quote:


How could a good God allow evil? Does God have omniscience? Omnipotence? Goodness?

First, you have to settle that God exists. Then you can work out these problems. Actually, Aquinas and other writers have already done it.

One of the primary strategities of atheists is to concentrate on one of these later problems, try to make you believe that nobody has the solution, ( although Aquinas does ! )
and therefore make you wonder if there's a God at all
since they haven't pointed to the point of this thread,
that an infinite past is impossible and God had to start the universe.

But they're not going to get away with that on this thread.
Your strategy is to focus on a solution that doesn't actually solve anything, and deal with the rest of it "later."

Your mistake is the assumption that atheists are necessarily more dogmatic than theists. It's not true, nor does it need to be. If Deism is true, my life goes on just as it has all long. But Christianity is instantly demolished.
  #12  
Old Feb 25, '12, 8:10 pm
Katholish's Avatar
Katholish Katholish is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: May 19, 2004
Posts: 1,015
Religion: Roman Rite Catholic
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by empther View Post
So far so good. I think. It's hard to know what you're saying.

It could not. I'm really surprised you said that. How could any event have happened an infinite time ago?

Even Aristotle said you can't go back to infinity and he did not have Revelation.
Actually, Aristotle is extremely well-known for his belief that the world is eternal. You seem to have that wrong.

St. Thomas addresses this question in Question 46 of the Prima Pars. Article 2 is especially helpful. In it, he says quite clearly, "I answer that, By faith alone do we hold, and by no demonstration can it be proved, that the world did not always exist..." St. Thomas was influenced very heavily on Aristotle's argument for the eternity of the world.

Aristotle presents his arguments in the Physics, and one of his more important points can be found in section 1,7:
Quote:
"Everything that comes into existence does so from a substratum. If the underlying matter of the universe came into existence, it would come into existence from a substratum. But the nature of matter is precisely to be the substratum from which other things arise. Consequently, the underlying matter of the universe could have come into evidence only from an already existing matter exactly like itself; to assume that the underlying matter of the universe came into existence would require assuming that an underlying matter already existed. The assumption is thus self-contradictory, and matter must be eternal."
Quote:
I think you mean effect, or cause and effect. Anyway, can you give an example of a cause and effect that does not occur within time?
No, I did not mean to say effect. Anyway, I can provide an example of an effect without a beginning in time. Actually, St. Thomas talks about this in the Reply to the First objection in Article 2, so I will just quote him:

Quote:
Reply to Objection 1. As Augustine says (De Civ. Dei xi, 4), the opinion of philosophers who asserted the eternity of the world was twofold. For some said that the substance of the world was not from God, which is an intolerable error; and therefore it is refuted by proofs that are cogent. Some, however, said that the world was eternal, although made by God. For they hold that the world has a beginning, not of time, but of creation, so that in a certain hardly intelligible way it was always made. "And they try to explain their meaning thus (De Civ. Dei x, 31): for as, if the foot were always in the dust from eternity, there would always be a footprint which without doubt was caused by him who trod on it, so also the world always was, because its Maker always existed." To understand this we must consider that the efficient cause, which acts by motion, of necessity precedes its effect in time; because the effect is only in the end of the action, and every agent must be the principle of action. But if the action is instantaneous and not successive, it is not necessary for the maker to be prior to the thing made in duration as appears in the case of illumination. Hence they say that it does not follow necessarily if God is the active cause of the world, that He should be prior to the world in duration; because creation, by which He produced the world, is not a successive change, as was said above (Question 45, Article 2).
__________________
Student of Systematic Theology at the Notre Dame Graduate School of Christendom College.

A good site to learn more about Catholic homeschooling:
Catholic Homeschooling
  #13  
Old Feb 25, '12, 8:15 pm
Katholish's Avatar
Katholish Katholish is offline
Regular Member
 
Join Date: May 19, 2004
Posts: 1,015
Religion: Roman Rite Catholic
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by Joe Kelley View Post
Science seems to have proven that the universe had a beginning in the Big Bang.

One must also consider that given sufficient time a system will pass through all possible states of change. Two of these states are 1. Perfection after which it no longer changes and 2. Annihilation after which it no longer exists. Given infinite time the universe would have reached one or the other long ago. Since it exists and is still changing, it must have experienced only a finite time.
Is there such a thing as a state of perfection for all matter? Even if there were, that would not necessarily imply a lack of subsequent change. Even if temporarily in a state of perfection, the potential to atrophy would still exist.

Annihilation would not be possible if you accept a theory like the conservation of matter and energy.
__________________
Student of Systematic Theology at the Notre Dame Graduate School of Christendom College.

A good site to learn more about Catholic homeschooling:
Catholic Homeschooling
  #14  
Old Feb 25, '12, 8:59 pm
TheTrueCentrist TheTrueCentrist is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: August 13, 2010
Posts: 2,561
Religion: Yours
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Quote:
Originally Posted by empther View Post
The universe could not have existed through an infinite past. Therefore, God had to start it.

Did any event happen an infinitely long time ago? Obviously not.

Now the atheists will try to talk about "non-linear time" or "imaginary time" or some nonsense like that. What they can't do is say how this takes the place of the linear time we experience. In fact it's nonsense.

The atheists will try to say there was some other cause of the universe. But another cause would in fact be part of the universe. Perhaps before the Big Bang there was something else. What? We can't imagine. And before that there may have been something else. And so on. But we can't go back to infinity. At some point we must arrive at a time when there was absolutely no universe in whatever form we want to think of it.

Therefore, there had to be a God to start it all.


Notice that Aquinas's Summa Theologica,
after discussing the nature of theology and why it's worth studying,
BEGINS BY DISCUSSING GOD'S EXISTENCE.

http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/aqui...mma/sum005.htm

Later,
he discusses other subjects such as the nature of evil and all those things.

But the athesits jump over the question of God's existence and try to confuse you with tons and tons of deceiving verbiage about the other issues such as the existence of evil, and things like that that understandably bother people.

We should follow Aquinas's example. First determine if God exists. Then work out the later problems later.
Problem: Existence instead of non-existence
Solution: Existence has always existed

You have decided to call the always existing existence God, but you have not considered any other possibilities.
  #15  
Old Feb 26, '12, 6:23 am
empther's Avatar
empther empther is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: July 8, 2004
Posts: 2,349
Religion: Catholic loyal to the Pope, don't even try to change me!
Default Re: Finite past proves God exists

Observe, friends, the shallow arguments of an atheist:

Quote:
ASimon wrote:
Your strategy is to focus on a solution that doesn't actually solve anything, and deal with the rest of it "later."
Do you all see the deception?
He’s hinting that my saying using Aquinas’s demonstration of God from the fact that we can’t go back to infinity is not a solution to any of the later problems, such as why there is evil etc etc.

What he doesn’t tell you,……………………

On second thought,
He doesn’t tell you two things.

The first is this: there’s no use tackling the later problems until you’ve settled that God does exist. Then you can talk about what God is doing or not doing.

As I’ve already said, the atheists want to do things in reverse. They will concentrate on the later problems, offer no solution, and lead you to think there is no God.

The second thing he doesn’t tell you is that one thread, a dozen threads, or this entire philosophy section couldn’t take care of all the later problems. This Amazon webpage offers Aquinas’s complete Summary of Theology:
http://www.amazon.com/Summa-Theologica-Thomas-Aquinas-Volumes/dp/0870610635/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=133026516 7&sr=1-2

Quote:
Divided into three parts, the work consists of 38 tracts, 631 questions, about 3000 articles, 10,000 objections and their answers. This complete edition of the work, published in five volumes,
 
10,0000 objections and their answeres. Do you think they’ll be settled on this forum?
Dream on!
Closed Thread

Go Back   Catholic Answers Forums > Forums > Apologetics > Philosophy

Bookmarks

Thread Tools Search Thread
Search Thread:

Advanced Search
Display

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump



Prayer Intentions

Most Active Groups
8246Meet and talk,talk talk
Last by: GLam8833
5010CAF Prayer Warriors Support Group
Last by: RJB
4343Devotion to the Sorrowful Mother
Last by: lsbar
4029OCD/Scrupulosity Group
Last by: B79
3830SOLITUDE
Last by: beth40n2
3561Let's empty Purgatory
Last by: James_OPL
3221Poems and Reflections
Last by: tonyg
3203Catholic Vegetarians & Vegans
Last by: memphian
3111Petitions Before the Blessed Sacrament
Last by: Amiciel
3047For seniors and shut- ins
Last by: Thomas Choe



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 1:13 am.

Home RSS Feeds - Home - Archive - Top

Copyright © 2004-2014, Catholic Answers.