Amnesty urges Iran to spare hanging survivor's life


Campaign group Amnesty International has urged Iran not to go ahead with a repeat execution for a drug smuggler who survived a botched hanging.

The condemned man, named as Alireza M, was found alive in a morgue after being hanged at a jail in the north-eastern city of Bojnord last week.

He is now being nursed to recovery in preparation for his repeat execution.

"The verdict was the death sentence, and it will be carried out once the man gets well again," an official said.

Human rights groups believe Iran is second only to China in the number of people it puts to death for crimes ranging from murder and rape to spying and drug-trafficking.

In a separate incident reported by Iranian media on Monday, relatives of a condemned murderer in the western province of Ilam tried to stop his execution at a prison by hurling a grenade.

Around 30 people were injured but the hanging went ahead.

'Horrific prospect'
Alireza M, 37, was left to hang for 12 minutes, after which a doctor declared him dead.

But when the prisoner's family went to collect his body from the prison morgue the next day, they found he was still breathing.

"We found him alive again, which made his two daughters very happy," an unnamed family member told Iranian state media.

The man was then moved to a hospital where he was being kept under armed guard.

"The horrific prospect of this man facing a second hanging, after having gone through the whole ordeal already once, merely underlines the cruelty and inhumanity of the death penalty," said Philip Luther, director of Amnesty International's Middle East and North Africa Programme, in a press release.

He called for both a stay of execution for the hanging survivor and a moratorium on all executions in Iran.

According to Amnesty, at least 508 people may have been executed in Iran this year to date. Most of those killed had been convicted of drug trafficking, it said.

"He is now being nursed to recovery in preparation for his repeat execution."
Wow, helping someone not to die but all still in preparation for his death. This is very, very disturbing. How sad. :mad:


If he must die, they could at least shoot him or something rather than have him go through the whole hanging ordeal again... :shrug:


You wouldn’t put a dog through this! I don’t believe in the death penalty as there have been too many people hanged under British justice that have subsequently been found innocent. Don’t do something irrevocable that you cannot explain to your God if you are mistaken. Surely this man has been punished enough. Prison is good enough. Let us pray for him.


There is no merciful way to end someone; but waiting for his neck to heal, only to break it, does seem to take vindictiveness to a new level.


I really hope that Iran spares this person's life but I don't think they will do so. I would like to see the death penalty abolished in all nations so long as they have other ways such as imprisonment to keep society safe from the criminal.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit