Annulments: Why does a Catholic Church Court need to determine whether the marriage was invalid?


#1

Can you help me understand why the Catholic Church Court needs to determine whether the marriage was invalid to annul the marriage?

Could you say something along the lines of priests were given authority by Jesus for the other Sacraments: (a) Reconciliation, (b) Holy Orders, © Communion, (d) Marriage – to determine whether someone is: (a) truly sorry for their sins to receive absolution; (b) is truly deemed a fit to the priesthood; © whether they have committed a mortal sin (outside of the confessional) and therefore may not receive communion; and (d) deemed a fit for a marriage (through Pre-Cana or other form) prior to receiving this Sacrament?

Any help (prior experiences, knowledge from sources, references in the Catechism) are greatly appreciated for my understanding when talking to others about this. Thank you!


#2

Lack of validity is usually the only grounds for a decree of nullity. A valid Christian marriage is indissoluble. There are a few cases where a natural marriage can be dissolved. e.g. Pauline privilege, Petrine privilege.


#3

Well… it doesn’t, strictly speaking.

After all, a marriage – when it’s been attempted to be celebrated properly, with all the attendant preparation and attention to detail – is presumed valid by the Church. The phrase you’ll hear, expressing this, is “marriage enjoys the favor of the law.”

So, the Church doesn’t need to determine whether a marriage is valid – if the attempt was there, in good faith, to make sure that it was valid at the time of the ceremony, then it’s presumed valid. Period.

But, if the marriage fails and one of the spouses asks the Church to investigate whether it was, in fact, valid – that is, s/he asks the Church to determine whether it was null or not – then the Church, who has the competency to regulate her own Sacraments, can investigate. Then, it makes a determination as to whether something essential was missing at the time of the ceremony, or if there was something standing in the way of a valid marriage at the time of the ceremony.

Marriage requires the consent of the spouses. If there were a lack of consent, or faulty consent, then the marriage can be declared null.

Marriage must be free from impediment. If there were an impediment present at the time of the ceremony (e.g., one of the spouses was not free to marry), then the marriage can be declared null.

For Catholics, marriage must be celebrated according to a prescribed form (i.e., in a Catholic church or chapel, by a priest or deacon). If this form was not followed, the marriage can be declared null.

If you want to read up on the particular issues which might cause a marriage to be declared null, I recommend Foster’s excellent book “Annulment: The Wedding that Was”.

As @PaulfromIowa mentions, there are (relatively rare) instances in which the Church may dissolve a marriage. In most cases, however, dissolution is not possible, but a case for nullity might be able to be made.

Does that help?


#4

A beter way to phrase it might be “why can’t a person make that determination for himself?”, in which case the answer is obvious.


#5

Because no one can undo what God has put together. The ONLY way a marriage can be “undone” is if the marriage wasn’t valid when it happened. That’s why the Catholic Church needs to determine whether the marriage was invalid or not when it happened. That’s the only way it can be annulled.


#6

That makes sense - thank you for your response!


#7

I appreciate the detailed response - thank you!


#8

The Tribunal has to determine whether the marriage was invalid or not before an annulment, because they don’t to accidentally allow a validly married couple to start living as if they weren’t married without just cause.


#9

This topic was automatically closed 14 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.