Are children of an annulment considered illegitimate?


#1

Someone I know has been married 3 times and divorced three times. She has been baptized in the Catholic church, confirmed and her first marriage is in the Catholic church. However, she did not attempt to get an anullment on any.

She recently spoke to a priest about coming back into communion with the Church. The first words out of the priest’s mouth were “Your children are illegitimate.” These children have all been baptized in the Church.

What’s the point of this statement, legally? Is it relevant to her re-entry into the Church? Is it irrelevant but serious? I understand illegitimate in reference to civil standing; but in the Church, I am sure that if I were an “illegitimate child” there would be no bar to my entry into the Church based upon that.

Can you shed any light upon this?


#2

Annulments by Jimmy Akin:

First of all, illegitimacy is a (as its name suggests) is legal category, and it pertains to man’s law, not God’s. It is no stain on the child in God’s eyes if the child was born in a valid marriage, an invalid marriage, or no marriage at all. The child is equally precious to God and the Church no matter how it was conceived.

Illegitimacy is a purely human legal category that is used for such things as determining inheritance rights. As a result, if a child is born in a marriage that is valid under civil law (even if it was invalid in God’s eyes) then the child is legitimate. Thus the Code of Canon Law states:
"1137. Children conceived or born of a valid or putative marriage are legitimate."
A marriage which was invalid under God’s law but valid under man’s would count as a putative marriage.
The Code also states:
· "1138-1. The father is he whom a lawful marriage indicates unless (nisi) evident arguments prove otherwise.
· "1138-2. Children are presumed to be legitimate if they are born at least 180 days after the celebration of the marriage or within 300 days from the date when conjugal life was terminated.
· "1139. Illegitimate children are rendered legitimate through the subsequent valid or putative marriage of their parents, or through a rescript of the Holy See.
· "1140. Insofar as canonical effects are concerned, legitimized children are equivalent in everything to legitimate children unless (nisi) the law expressly states otherwise."
So the only case when a child would not be legitimate would be if it was conceived by parents who were not married even under man’s law and if they never got married. And even then legitimacy is only used for determining things like inheritance rights; it has no religious or moral significance concerning the child, who is equally precious in the eyes of God and the Church no matter how it was conceived.

Article


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.