Are Hebrew Catholics in line with the Church?


#1

There are Jewish Catholics who call themselves “Hebrew Catholics.” They follow Jewish traditions like kosher eating and celebrate Jewish holidays. They also follow the Law of Moses, yet they believe in Jesus and are faithful to the teachings of the Magisterium and were approved by John Paul II.

Is it legalism to follow Torah and Jewish customs if you want to?


#2

It sounds as though there has been some misunderstanding about Hebrew Catholics. Although there may be some who identify with the Hebrew Catholic movement who keep kosher and the Law of Moses, that is not something that is being advocated for by Hebrew Catholics as a movement. There are Evangelical Protestants known as Messianic Jews who believe in keeping kosher and the Law of Moses but they are not Catholics.

The Hebrew Catholics I’ve met are fully in line with Church teaching that observance of the Law of Moses (including Jewish holidays and kosher eating) is no longer binding upon Catholics (Hebrew and Gentile alike) *at all *(cf. Col. 2:13-17). To the extent that Hebrew Catholics I’ve known acknowledge and celebrate the Jewish holidays, for example, the intent has been to respect and maintain their heritage and not to observe a non-existent obligation.

For more information about the beliefs of Hebrew Catholics, I recommend visiting the site of the Association of Hebrew Catholics.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.