Atheist claims discrimination at Scottish Catholic school


#1

Glasgow, May. 25 (CWNews.com) - Scottish Church authorities vetoed the appointment of Catholic teachers who divorced and remarried, an employment tribunal heard yesterday.

Catholic teachers who sent their own children to non-religious schools were also banned from “reserved posts” in Church establishments, reports the Scottish Daily Record .

David McNab, a math teacher at St. Paul’s Roman Catholic High School in Pollok, Glasgow, has taken the city council before an employment tribunal, claiming religious discrimination. He says he was not considered for the post of head of pastoral care because he is an atheist.

McNab, 53, told the Glasgow tribunal he was made to feel like a “second-class citizen” when the school’s head-teacher told him he could not be considered as the job required Catholic approval. Sectarian schools in Scotland are run by local governments.

The council deny discrimination on the grounds of religion or religious belief.

Keir Bloomer, a former deputy director of education with Strathclyde Regional Council, told the tribunal Catholic teachers seeking jobs at Catholic schools had to gain Church approval.

He explained that teachers of “reserved” subjects like religious and moral education, as well as pastoral care staff, are expected to be Catholic and have to satisfy the local Church of their “religious belief and character.” This condition does not apply to non-Catholics applying for ‘non-reserved’ posts.

Bloomer, now chief executive of Clackmannanshire Council, was asked why the Church may not approve of some Catholic teachers.

He replied, “Being divorced and remarried tended to be something the Church regarded as a just cause for withdrawing approval.”

McNab claims a law banning discrimination on the grounds of religious belief means he should have been allowed to apply. The case continues.


#2

It’s true I think - the new discrimination laws in the UK include religious discrimination, which is a good thing to include of course.

However, wise people at the time did try to amend the law so that religious establishments should be excluded from the law. This was not included.

So in theory it is illegal to stop someone from being a priest/minister/pastor of a church just on the grounds that they are a buddhist or muslim or whatever else. Of course in theory I couldn’t be barred from running a mosque solely on the grounds that I am a Catholic. Which is all very silly, but that’s the way the law currently stands.


#3

Not the first complaint we have had,but this is just a dodge to get religion out of schools.If you type Scottish Catholic Observer or
Catholic Times UK into your search engine,you may just get something about this:-

sundayherald.com/49323

P.S.This school is within walking distance of where i live.


#4

[quote=burnside]Not the first complaint we have had,but this is just a dodge to get religion out of schools.If you type Scottish Catholic Observer or
Catholic Times UK into your search engine,you may just get something about this:-

sundayherald.com/49323

P.S.This school is within walking distance of where i live.
[/quote]

Correct. The not very hidden agenda is to get religion - and more particularly Catholicism - out of the schools. All these media led claims must be understood against that background.


#5

The media is still keeping this one going:-

eveningtimes.co.uk/hi/news/5039260.html


#6

I don’t know whether to laugh or cry. This is absurd! You would expect that sending your children to Catholic school, that they are going to be insulated from the secular influence around us all for a couple of hours each day.

By the way, “Hello, Scotland!” My maternal grandfather was a Macdonald - and proud of it! :wave:


#7

Very absurd


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.