BOOKS: The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ by Philip Pullman

For those who don’t recall, Pullman is also the author of the atheistic “His Dark Materials” trilogy (written for children as an anti-Narnia), the first of which (“The Golden Compass”) was made into a movie.

Carl Olson has blogged about some of the plot off the book (even though he hasn’t read it yet):

It just came out on April 1st, which was both “April Fool’s Day” and Holy Thursday (i.e. the start of the Sacred Triduum, the high point of the Christian Year). I can’t imagine that not being a deliberate choice for a release date.

Basically, it’s a novel about how Mary had twins: the humble, good, somewhat dim-witted “Jesus”, and the cunning, not-so-good “Christ”. “Christ” conspires to have “Jesus” killed so he can start a new religion.

Before we get too worked up about it, note that it is currently ranked #44,903 in books on Even the “old news” Da Vinci Code is ranked considerably higher (#7,733). And Scott Hahn’s The Lamb’s Supper beats them both (#3,865 :)). Thus, the book does not seem destined to make many waves at this point.

It seems like Pullman is trying to pull a Dan Brown and cash in with a “provocative” work that “reimagines” Christianity. I doubt he will succeed. His children’s books weren’t nearly as successful as their counterparts (Narnia and Harry Potter). He just doesn’t have the audience. Which is good news for us. :slight_smile: But, I like to be aware of these things just in case I encounter it.

I’ve got better things to do with my time, of course, than to read or watch any Pullman story.

We won’t likely be seeing any sequel to The Golden Compass anytime soon. It ranks as one of the worst American box office draws in relation to its budget. Without the foreign take, it would have been a total loser at the box office.

Pullman can, thank God, (pun intended) write whatever he wants too. He clearly has talent. Also, we can say whatever we want to about whatever he writes. I haven’t read anything by him, though Golden Compass is on my list. This one won’t be.

God help him.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit