“Catholics for Choice”, the words taken in a literal sense is not an oxymoron, because Catholics are allowed to make choices about lots of things, eg, what colour socks to wear. But “Catholics for Choice regarding Abortion” is an oxymoron (5th commandment anyone?) I guess that’s why they don’t write out their name like that (-:
Um, back to the original question. Not that I think that that is a reputable source, but even if that did happen, would it actually be wrong? Contraceptives are wrong because they prevent conception. But, for example, let’s say I put on a condom but then don’t have sex, and later take off the condom. That isn’t wrong. So the same for nuns taking contraceptives, if they don’t have sex then it isn’t wrong. And if they get raped, well it’s not like they were planning on getting raped! It’s not their fault that they had sex while using contraception. So then they didn’t do anything wrong.
Of course, this is a pretty ‘technical’ argument, since the whole reason that they were using contracpetion (if it did actually happen) was because they expected that they might get raped. It’s a bit of a ‘loophole’, I wonder if God would be alright with it…
But yea, if the people on that site really do want to push this sotry, then maybe we should concede to them that they are allowed to use contraceptives, just like the nuns did - as long as they don’t have sex while using them. I’m not sure why anyone would want that, but there you go.