Death penalty question


#1

What does the Church say about the death penalty, especially about the execution of mentally disabled criminals?


#2

I believe the Church is against the death penalty in all cases. It would be a “pro-life” issue.


#3

The Church is not always against the death penalty (see the CCC 2267)

It provides for a very limited use which is almost unneeded in this day and age.


#4

One Sparrow is correct, the death penalty is only licit in cases where there is no other way to effectively protect society as a whole to a reasonable degree (CCC 2267 and Evangelium Vitae).

The mental capacity of the criminal doesn't really enter into that equation, but it does help highlight why the Church teaches that, in the US, where some states do execute the mentally infirm, the practice feeds into an overall culture of death (see the United States Catholic Catechism for Adults, Chapter 29).

Pax Christi


#5

Thank you all.


#6

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.