I didn’t want to derail the other thread so I started my own from the question that arose from some of the responses there.
From another thread:
Response I received from another poster:
Addressing the bolded, I have no issue in ceding that all truth comes from God. I do believe that other religions contain some truths, but the Catholic Church claims it has the fullness of truth, so how is it that Greek pagans knew about these truths well before Catholics did? Claiming these philosophies as our own, or having “developed and evolved them in a Christian context” still seems much like piggybacking on the philosophies of pagans and repackaging them to fulfill our needs, bringing us back to square one.
Any other posters feel free to jump in and reply, too.