Have enough kids and don't trust NFP, options?

It isn’t one instance. Or anecdotal.

Use of oral contraceptive, the patch, the ring, etc, increases the risk of Ischemic stroke. Dramatically in women with other risk factors including migraines, hypertension, smokers, etc.

Edited to add: their own websites list blood clot and strokes as risks of OCPs.

1 Like

BCPs increase the risk of stroke by 1.9 percent.

1.9%?

WebMD gives 1 in 24,000.

Or 0.004%. Moreover, the vast majority of women who have a stroke on the pill have other risk factors or took it improperly.

An overdose on estrogen does increase the odds of a clot forming.

For healthy women the risk from normal use is repeatedly summarized as “none” from the 3 or 4 peer reviews your bogus number prompted me to look up.

Luckily for all women, the time in her life when she needs to be more stroke conscious is generally the same time she can throw them away.

@Hume

Personally I would like to ad it that I have used artificial method of birth control, but the stroke risks with birth control pills I believe unfortunately are not just relevant for the women of menopause age.
There are a good amount of very overweight young women in society, and it’s suggested they can be 30 times more likely to develop a Cerebral Venous Thrombosis stroke when taking birth control pill.
The risk of stroke is also increased in women who have Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome ( which often come with overweight, high cholesterol, high blood pressure) and also is increased in smokers, women with migraine history or women with family history of DVT and heart disease etc…
I think this risk is only for the combined pill because of the Estrogen and the progestin only pill doesn’t carry this risk.
Pill containing Estrogen can increase “procoagulant factors” (leading to the blood clot).

Obesity itself causes excess Estrogen as the body fat itself produces Estrogen. My guess is this has sone connection to why they at higher risk for increase procoagulation/clot but this is only my guess.
To complicated things further “estrogens aren’t estrogens” -Ie: there is good and bad types. Doctors rarely consider this!

Interesting though, even pregnancy itself can have stroke risk for the same above women (increase procoagulant factors, blood pressure, gestational diabetes etc)…

If not smoke, not overweight etc probably fine.

1 Like

Something being artificial or natural has zero moral bearing on any sort of contraception issue. The moral issue is not who creates latex, hormones, or herbal tea.

1 Like

The consequence, all four of them, she very much has been pleased with, in fact to the point of wanting a fifth which I do not. The physical act during non-fertile times is a chore for her that brings no pleasure and is not something she enjoys in any way.

My plan was to get clipped and had a pre-check appointment. The actual date I was offered was only two days after which gave me too little time to think it over. I’m reluctantly still ok with it, knowing it’s a sin, she is not and I will not do something like that with her being completely object to it.

Planning on doing anything when the kids need to be unconscious can be difficult. Last year on 12/24 we simply didn’t sleep getting things ready, we may have dosed off around 3am Christmas morning but given their excitement they were up before 6am.

Perhaps I am not understanding the Catholic teaching properly, but doesn’t this seem a bit like splitting hairs?
I mean, technically, deciding to not have sex during fertile periods could be also considered a form of birth control.

I understand that the Catholic Church accepts this, and that couples might not anyway have been having sex continually non stop always :wink:
but technically a baby could have been “gifted by God” during that period and a “human means” has interrupted it.
That’s why I find it hard to see much difference between NFP & condoms (or natural treatment) when used by couples who already have a general attitude/mindset of being open to babies & consider them a blessing.

As an aside I’m not sure I understand even whether God is directly involved in pregnancies or if it is just “biological process” (even if the biological process created by God).
To explain it clearer words, I mean if a couple has 10 children does that mean that God himself “gifted” them 10 children intentionally or does it just mean they have certain biological factors (high fertility) which resulted in 10 children and therefor a “passive process”?

I love big families but I also read some bad story from USA like Turbin family abuse story who had many children.
It possible they could have been just as abusive with 3 children but this besides the point here. What I am trying to understand though is their number of children Gods direct doing?

Nfp is good in general though, even just to be in tune with body is good.

I’m only asking this for my own understanding and not for controversy or want arguments.
(I feel almost a need to put this “disclaimer” to remind anyone who responds to please respond in a respectful way.
It is possible for people to have different opinions and keep it pleasant/without harshness or aggression etc.)

1 Like

My point was simply that “man made” thing is not morally unacceptable simply because it is man made. That would be ridiculous. So a sheepskin condom is somehow better morally than a latex one?

a general mindset of openess is not enough. We have to proove it by our action, our choise every time we have marital intimacy. That’s mean to not change the nature of the act or our fertility deliberately (separate the unitive and the procreative meaning). Condoms prevents the seed to go to his natural place and natural “treatment” is a mean to reduce the likelihood of conception deliberately. It is nothing “natural”.
NFP, when it is chosen with an open mind to children does not separate the meaning of sexuality. It is still the same act, ordered toward procreation, that can lead to a baby. It is just a choose to do or avoid in a certain timing.

1 Like

Thankyou for the sheepskin visual :sheep: :blush:.
Though latex can actually be made from natural materials too, but by natural I wasn’t really referring to natural materials themselves but things that were “artificially created” by humans to reduce fertility vs natural things that did this anyway (eg: herbs or sauna heat).

Either way, another poster clarified that the Catholic Church was against all methods.

It is birth control. But birth control isn’t intrinsically immoral/evil. Contraception is an intrinsically evil means of birth control. Abstaining isn’t.

In one you refrain from the act, in the other you engage in the act while disordering it with a condom.

This is called proportionality and it has been condemned by the Church. Dr Janet Smith has a great talk on this.

Usually the latter, in extraordinary cases— John the Baptist, Isaac, etc.— likely directly.

There are families with one child that are abusers. No, abuse is not driven by a large family. It is driven by mental health, addictions, anger issues, personality disorders, and the like.

No. God gives us free will and cooperated with our choices.

1 Like

You HAVE to take a couple to couple league CLASS and LEARN NFP. I’m sorry y’all got to the point of fear of intimacy before figuring this out. Truly. I keep running into so many young couples in this same boat. Why aren’t they pushing the classes at engagement encounter weekends?

NFP really does work if you take the class and chart. I don’t even chart my temp any longer. We’ve been together 20 years & have 5 children. BUT, they were all conceived while both of us knew we were fertile but had enough wine that neither of us cared & were just like “it’s God will!” Lol. We are happy and my husband is one of 5 and always wanted 5 so all is well. But not everyone is mentally and/or emotionally equipped for 5. So I get it that you’re feeling this way.

We really don’t want anymore. Our babies were 10 pounds and I’m small, so physically & considering complications after the last births I don’t think it would be good for me. And I’m enjoying our life free of diapers for the first time in 18years!! So we now have a “designated” natural family planner if we’re fertile. I rarely drink now that I’m approaching 40/get headaches from only 1 drink, so it’s not really a problem to be “designated” :wink:

I know some couples who are like y’all and didn’t take a class and can’t financially support another child after having 4 due to private school tuition (we are in a city with some of the worst public schools in the nation) so these couples began using condoms if anywhere near the fertile window. I told them if they take the class and chart they wont need to do that. But they’re terrified, and I get it, so I don’t judge. Some Priests have told them they’ve “done their duty” and God understands. Some tell them to take the class and trust in the Lord.

The class is around an hour for 4 weekends or so. It’s EXTREMELY informative. Also, i highly recommend PAPER charting and not using an app. You have to see the month all laid out in front of you on paper to really “get it”

Oh and it’s really your wife that would be charting- not you. There’s really no mood breaker. She would know if she is or isn’t in the fertile window before the mood strikes y’all. As for her not being interested in sex - it’s probably because she feels like nothing but a mom and like everyone just wants a piece of her in some way. I felt this way a lot especially while breastfeeding exclusively. I just couldn’t get in “that“ mood. Things are fantastic now though. All the kids are weaned and out of diapers and I feel like a woman and a mom not JUST a mom.

it’s important for her to periodically feel desirable and to desire you even in the midst of the sweet chaos of little ones, so Take her out to dinner. Tell her she’s beautiful. Talk to her in her eyes at dinner. She might need that to get of out “mom mode”. And if y’all drink, have a drink before so she lets her hair down a little. For some gals, it’s hard to go from mom mode to feeling desirable mode. A cocktail or 2 can make all the difference in relaxing her and quieting her thoughts of “the kids”

Good luck! Oh and pray together every night as a fam. Even if it’s just one Our Father and One Hail Mary.

3 Likes

There are many other methods of NFP. CtCL teaches the Sympto Thermal method. This method is not practical for some people, like me! I encourage people to investigate STM, STM + Tech/Marquette, Tech only, Creighton, Billings, that gives a person the opportunity to find what will work for you right now and in the future.

1 Like

Well if you want sex with a guarantee infertility, then that’s kinda impossible… without immoral measures.

1 Like

This defines our problem almost exactly. She has a pretty good hold on when she’s fertile and that alone is enough to make me want to avoid contact. It also happens to be the only time she even has a chance of finding herself in the mood. Part of it is psychological and part of it is hormonal. I can help with the psychological part dealing with the kids, dishes, chores, etc. leaving her with less to stress about but the hormonal part I have zero control over and the only hormonal control pills I’ve found are birth control pills, leading us back to the original problem.

This is making more sense to me every day: " The one who loves his life will lose it , and the one who hates his life in this world will keep it for eternal life."

I think this may be part of your issue. How much of that is hyperbole and how much do you actually avoid her? Make sure you aren’t pulling back too much from her.

1 Like

When I say avoid, I mean avoid sex to put it bluntly. I don’t avoid her in any other way, we’re physically close to one another, we look at old pictures together, watch a favorite TV show together, discuss what we’re grateful for and what might be bothering us. In the rare instance when one of us needs to be left alone, we grant each other the solitude needed but it’s not often and never more than a couple hours.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.