Ok, I’ve just looked this up, but having looked up Cosmology and Astronomy from the top experts in the field, I’m extremely skeptical on the idea of Geocentrism. I know it’s not a matter of morality or dogma, but it still seems strange to me that modern people would think too hard about it; since from what I’ve seen, Heliocentrism is proven in just about every way.
The thing I’ve noticed about Geocentric Theory today is that it’s based on the idea that all we see is the entire Universe. The work of master physicists and men like Stephen Hawking (Regardless of his anti-religious ideas, he’s one of the most brilliant men ever to live, and I trust him on matters of Cosmology pretty well), and other Cosmologists have taken away the key idea for a Geocentric Universe, which I see as problematic for the modern theory.
Again, this is not a matter of Faith or Morals, and the Church could have certainly been wrong on this.
Actually, it is modern science that is credited with too much, I think. See this thread, it talks about the relation between our observations, the assumptions made, and the resulting interpretations. See especially the exchange between trth-skr and psteichen.
Really, modern science itself is not claiming too much. Scientists such as Hawking admit that many of the foundational issues are actually assumptions. I think it is the science propagandists who then claim that the assumptions are actually fact- often by just stating it without explanation. For instance, they may say, “every place in the universe looks like the center” rather than the more factually correct “scientists assume [for sake of modesty] that every place in the universe looks like the center”.
According to the opinions used to condemn Galileo, as well as place certain books on the index, it was “at least erroneous in faith”, so in that sense it was considered a matter of faith.
However, would you say that one could be a Heliocentric supporter and still a good Catholic?
I honestly have no doubt about the origin (In fact, to my Faith, Helio/Geocentrism is irrelevant) of it all, I just tend to side with Modern Science on this one particular issue. Regardless of which is actually correct, God is still the author and creator of it all.