I'm in a Christian debate about Saul, the witch of Endor and Samuel and would appreciate any thoughts on this.
My first thoughts were adamant that this wasn't Samuel but the witch's familiar spirit as it is an abomination to conjure up the dead. Then another posted who is strong in his faith said that God can do anything, and that when Samuel came the witch screamed and was very afraid, suggesting that she didn't know the spirit, therefore it may indeed have been that of Samuel. That the message given was bad for Saul who had lost favour with God. That it was God this came from.
Now, I believe that our Lord God can do anything but do you think that this was in fact the spirit of Samuel in a unique and one off situation or was it a demon?
I ask myself now how could this be God who, in allowing Samuel to come back to speak to Saul in such a way, is basically condoning the very thing he detests.