How do you feel about the Sign of Peace?


#1

Okay, so the Sign of Peace is definitely a nice sentiment. But I really don’t enjoy shaking people’s hands. Especially in the winter with cold and flu season. It would be one thing if it was AFTER taking the Eucharist, but it’s not. So you watch someone sneeze, then s/he shakes your hand, and then you go up, get the Eucharist in your hands, and in goes the Body of Christ and all of your fellow parishioners’ germs.

Does anyone else feel this way?


#2

I don’t.


#3

While I support giving some sign of peace, I share your concern, especially during cold and flu season.

My dh takes medication that weakens his immune system and a simple cold can easily turn into bronchitis or pneumonia. It is very difficult to avoid shaking hands (though one could clasp one’s own hands together while saying “Peace be with you” and smiling genuinely) so we keep a small discreet (we hope) bottle of hand sanitizer which we use just before going up for Communion, slipping it out of and then back into a pocket. There are not many other choices.


#4

[quote="dixieagle, post:3, topic:266663"]
While I support giving some sign of peace, I share your concern, especially during cold and flu season.

My dh takes medication that weakens his immune system and a simple cold can easily turn into bronchitis or pneumonia. It is very difficult to avoid shaking hands (though one could clasp one's own hands together while saying "Peace be with you" and smiling genuinely) so we keep a small discreet (we hope) bottle of hand sanitizer which we use just before going up for Communion, slipping it out of and then back into a pocket. There are not many other choices.

[/quote]

I use sanitizer too.


#5

[quote="Angela77, post:1, topic:266663"]
Okay, so the Sign of Peace is definitely a nice sentiment. But I really don't enjoy shaking people's hands. Especially in the winter with cold and flu season. It would be one thing if it was AFTER taking the Eucharist, but it's not. So you watch someone sneeze, then s/he shakes your hand, and then you go up, get the Eucharist in your hands, and in goes the Body of Christ and all of your fellow parishioners' germs.

Does anyone else feel this way?

[/quote]

I do not like it at all, especially at its current place in the modern Roman Rite. Inasmuch as we would like to keep it, it should probably be moved to the Offertory, but I find it so disruptive I'd rather see it go altogether. The* Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum* should be sufficient.


#6

One option is to clasp your hands together and nod or give some idea that you are responding, then when you go to receive the Eucharist … receive it on the tongue.


#7

I think it is disruptive and makes things uncomfortable that otherwise might be fine, between parishioners. Sometimes I am deep in prayer / meditation and v sensitive and emotional during mass. It feels weird to break that and also think ok now everyone is awkwardly saying hi to the girl who was crying at mass. I think that diminishes my chances of just getting to know them normally, maybe? Why not more coffee and donuts events after mass? But then I prefer TLM, just wish it was daily in my area.

As for germs I have never had a problem w not shaking hands bc germs. Just wave and smile.


#8

[quote="Angela77, post:1, topic:266663"]
Okay, so the Sign of Peace is definitely a nice sentiment. But I really don't enjoy shaking people's hands. Especially in the winter with cold and flu season. It would be one thing if it was AFTER taking the Eucharist, but it's not. So you watch someone sneeze, then s/he shakes your hand, and then you go up, get the Eucharist in your hands, and in goes the Body of Christ and all of your fellow parishioners' germs.

Does anyone else feel this way?

[/quote]

While I certainly sympathise with the hygiene issue, I hate it when parishoners give half-hearted handshakes or wave (unless they're far away or ill--but in the second case, why come to Mass?) even in the winter. It's rude.

Your parish should keep hand sanitiser, or you should keep a bottle of it in your pocket during Mass.


#9

I’m not a mad fan of the “sign of peace” thing and I don’t think I would miss it one bit if it were discontinued. But, it’s really not that big of a deal to me, so, I just do it and don’t think much of it.
As for the worry about communion, germs, etc., I prefer communion on the tongue so germs aren’t an issue for me.


#10

It’s never bothered me as I’ve always done it.

I haven’t done it much lately though as I am holding a baby and people just nod instead. Maybe that’s what you need? :smiley:


#11

And interesting side note… When I’ve gone to Masses done my bishop, he doesn’t do the Sign of Peace.


#12

[quote="Bezant, post:8, topic:266663"]
While I certainly sympathise with the hygiene issue, I hate it when parishoners give half-hearted handshakes or wave (unless they're far away or ill--but in the second case, why come to Mass?) even in the winter. It's rude.

Your parish should keep hand sanitiser, or you should keep a bottle of it in your pocket during Mass.

[/quote]

What if the other person is ill? Obviously ill, coughing, wiping their dripping nose on their hands? And yet he still wants to grab your hand. I've seen it.

Not fond of the placing of the Sign of Peace, but it's not up to me.


#13

St. Francis kissed the leper, "and that which was bitter became sweet."

And the leper revealed himself as Christ.

Maybe the sign of peace is a challenge to us to reach out and embrace the Christ that is within us all: the Christ we are soon to meet in the Eucharist.

If we can't greet Christ in the pew next to us, how can we dare consume Christ in the Host?:shrug:


#14

I think hand shake is outdated. Let's us a simple nod of the head.


#15

[quote="Sailor_Kenshin, post:12, topic:266663"]
What if the other person is ill? Obviously ill, coughing, wiping their dripping nose on their hands? And yet he still wants to grab your hand. I've seen it.

Not fond of the placing of the Sign of Peace, but it's not up to me.

[/quote]

While i'm no germaphobe, If I had the common cold, I would just wave and say "peace".


#16

It's optional, like incense and Both Species. A priest can choose not to do the SoP for no good reason. I think there's no good reason to have it, personally.


#17

[quote="Angela77, post:1, topic:266663"]
Okay, so the Sign of Peace is definitely a nice sentiment. But I really don't enjoy shaking people's hands. Especially in the winter with cold and flu season. It would be one thing if it was AFTER taking the Eucharist, but it's not. So you watch someone sneeze, then s/he shakes your hand, and then you go up, get the Eucharist in your hands, and in goes the Body of Christ and all of your fellow parishioners' germs.

Does anyone else feel this way?

[/quote]

One of my favorite aspects of the EF low mass is kneeling at the Sanctus, adoring Him when the host and chalice is raised, and then praying in the presence of the body, blood, soul and divinity for His mercy, and His healing so that I may be a worthy vessel for Him when I receive. I've had some very profound praying experiences in those quiet moments. And I don't have to move or touch anyone during the entire time.

When I'm not in the mood to touch anyone at an OF mass, I simply look at them, sniffle and wave a bit, and say "Peace Be With You." I find a strategically timed nose blow helps with this strategy as well. I always receive on the tongue, OF or EF, from the priest who has washed his hands before the consecration, so the sacrament contamination thing is never really an issue for me (unless the priest touches my tongue with his fingers - ew!).


#18

I'm not a big fan of the sign of peace, but I do it. I'm a total germaphobe as well! In the winter, I usually end up keeping my coat and gloves on because the parish I go to is always so cold! Hand sanitizer is good. Communion on the tongue is better ;), but that's just me!


#19

[quote="105lynne, post:18, topic:266663"]
I'm not a big fan of the sign of peace, but I do it. I'm a total germaphobe as well! In the winter, I usually end up keeping my coat and gloves on because the parish I go to is always so cold! Hand sanitizer is good. Communion on the tongue is better ;), but that's just me!

[/quote]

One of the things that amused me greatly when I converted was noticing that Catholics keep their coats on in church. At the LDS wards when I was growing up, there was alway a big coat rack in the foyer area where most people hung their coats. But Catholics, they keep their coats on, I guess because of the space they take up in a pew or something.

When I keep my long black cloak on in church (because of temperature, room, etc), I always feel like Batman. Except for, you know, the lacy veil on my head. :D


#20

[quote="HonoraDominum, post:19, topic:266663"]
One of the things that amused me greatly when I converted was noticing that Catholics keep their coats on in church. At the LDS wards when I was growing up, there was alway a big coat rack in the foyer area where most people hung their coats. But Catholics, they keep their coats on, I guess because of the space they take up in a pew or something.

When I keep my long black cloak on in church (because of temperature, room, etc), I always feel like Batman. Except for, you know, the lacy veil on my head. :D

[/quote]

In my Parish, there is a coat room. I do take my coat off and keep it with me, but if there's an issue of making room n the pew, I will place the coat on my lap while sitting.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.