If the supposedly disinterested person was a Disneyland - Dwelling Westerner who didn’t know jack about the subject — like that it is NOT about his honor , and IS about the lives of more than just his daughter —
well, of course.
You do rather funny things with the word , " religious" .
Like I get the impression you are very religious, but avoid applying the word to yourself because your religion sucks , even for you.
" Whatever " is correct. .
Not in this particular case.
Let us say that, hypothetically, atheists are correct, and dead means dead.
If I rape you , torture you, and then kill you , for fun , that isn’t going to be wrong for you. That isn’t even going to hurt your feelings. Because you won’t exist.
Likewise it doesn’t matter much whether I gloat over it , or come to regret it to a profound degree, because, soon enough , I likewise will cease to exist.
By extension , barring anything but the most extreme wishful thinking, in due course anyone who knew you, anyone who knew me, will likewise pass into nothingness.
It is perhaps giving to much credit to say that in a mere 100 years, none will be any the wiser whether I was Mother Theresa or Jack the Ripper. None will know that you were wronged , or even that you existed for that matter , and that is among people who are still breathing.
By extension , barring anything but the most extreme wishful thinking, in due course , not a single human will exist to say that killing you for fun was good or bad.
It seems to me that things like good and bad are unavoidably predicated on my existence and yours .
If you and I don’t exist, then the point itself doesn’t exist.
God this or God that not withstanding.
I frankly don’t trust theists who obviously have distinct motives when it comes to food, drink, fashion , and cronies, but claim to love God without motive.
I certainly have no regard at all for atheists who play very funny games with time.