In Defense of Heresy


Not in defense of commiting it, but in calling it what it is.

Here is an excerpt from a column by Bishop Rene Henry Gracida entitled “Now Is The Time” that appeared in Catholic Exchange:

We Catholics tend to become very defensive about the word “heresy.” Often when the subject of heresy and heretics comes up accusations are leveled in which the name of the Inquisition is invoked. Even today, one frequently reads a news item about the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in the secular press in which the Congregation is identified as “the former Holy Office in charge of the Inquisition.”

Critics of the Spanish Inquisition over the centuries have made categorical and stereotypical errors by falsely holding the Catholic Church responsible for certain atrocities. That which men in the Church were guilty of during the Spanish Inquisition, and that which the Church of that time is falsely accused of, are irrelevant to the reality of heresy per se. There is no need to shy from the reality of heresy because of abuses committed in its name, or abuses which the state, and not the Church was guilty of. We have become reluctant to admit to ourselves that heresy can be a reality in these modern times.

To see the entire column go to:


:clapping: :amen: What a bishop !!!


This is what we all need. A bishop with the guts to call a spade a spade and make no apologies for doing so.

Gerry :slight_smile:


Historically, heresy has sometimes served a purpose–in that by misunderstanding an article of faith or re-stating an article of faith in the wrong way, it has forced the Church to think through just what it believes and how to express it.

As an example, the Church always believed that Jesus was the Christ, the Son of God, and was truly God and truly man. But soon someone was sayiing (and I’m sure someone else can give the name of the particular heretic involved) that Jesus was truly God but only appeared to be human. Or that Christ did not have a human will but only a divine will. Or that Christ was truly man, but not truly God.

The Church had to say, wait a minute, that is not what we have always believed. Now how can we express our belief in a more exact way?


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit