Ireland says no

The Lisbon treaty was defeated in Ireland this Friday 13th June, and thank God.
I hate their sleight of hand ways of trying to force abortion on us, and their corrupt equality laws, and then they wold squeeze religious freedom, just like Christmas was banned in Ireland in days gone by. etc; etc; etc

But I’m sure those Eurocrats will try to conjure up some-other concoction to ram down our throats.

Irish voters have rejected the Lisbon Treaty.

With results in from all 43 constituencies, the Lisbon Treaty has been defeated by a margin of 53.4% to 46.6%.
A total of 752,451 people voted in favour of the treaty and 862,415 voted against.
Just 10 constituencies - Clare, Dublin South, Dublin South East, Dublin North, Dublin North Central, Dún Laoghaire, Kildare North, Laois Offaly, Carlow Kilkenny and Meath East - voted in favour of the Treaty.


Praying that they will find no way to do that!!
So happy that Ireland remains a land free from abortion, God bless you all:shamrock2:

Thank God!

Church and State
The EU is a secular body, i.e., there is a separation of church and state. There are no formal ties to any religion and no mention of religion in any current or proposed treaty.[11] Discussion over the draft texts of the European Constitution and later the Treaty of Lisbon have included proposals to mention Christianity and/or God in the preamble of the text. This call has been supported by Christian religious leaders, most notably the Pope.[12] However explicit inclusion of a link to religion faced opposition from secularists and the final Constitution referred to Europe’s “Religious and Humanist inheritance”. A second attempt to include Christianity in the treaty was undertaken in 2007 with the drafting of the Treaty of Lisbon. Angela Merkel promised the Pope that she would use her influence during Germany’s presidency to try to include a reference to Christianity and God in this replacement for the constitution. This has provoked opposition, not least in the German press,[13] and as this inclusion may have caused problems in reaching a final agreement, this attempt was given up.[14] Of the Union’s 27 states, only five have an official state religion, these being Cyprus (Cypriot Orthodox Church), Denmark (Danish National Church), Greece (Church of Greece), Malta (Roman Catholic Church) and England in the UK (Church of England). (Some other churches have a close relationship with the state.[15])

In the secularising EU, The Vatican has been vocal against a perceived “militant atheism”. It based this on a number of events, for example; the rejection of religious references in the Constitution and Treaty of Lisbon, the rejection by Parliament of Rocco Buttiglione as Justice Commissioner in 2004,[12] while at the same time Parliament approved Peter Mandelson (who is gay[16]) as Trade Commissioner, and the legalisation of same-sex marriage in countries such as the Netherlands, Belgium, and Spain.[12] The European Parliament has also been calling for same-sex marriages to be recognised across the EU.[17] Meanwhile, states such as Latvia and Poland [18] have rejected legislation designed to stop discrimination against homosexuals. This has been stated to be on religious grounds, with homosexual behaviour described as “degenerate” and “unnatural”, and the Catholic church influencing public opinion. The difference of opinion between these countries and Brussels has been damaging relations.[19][15]

Keep on fighting Irish people!

Ireland is the only country in the EU with the courage to put the treaty to a popular vote.

It is an embarrassment too to the other 26 leaders across Europe who, for fear of a similar outcome, have refused to stage popular votes and left the ratification process to more easily managed parliamentarians.

Critics of the constitutional treaty in their countries will now renew their ‘we were robbed’ protests, pointing out that in the only country where voters were allowed a say the people have rejected the institutional reforms.

Indeed, since the voters in France and the Netherlands in 2005 rejected the previous effort to provide the EU with a constitution the question arises whether any EU enterprise of this kind is capable of passing the test of a popular vote.

It is indeed and though I am a strong supporter of Europen co-operation I was for many reasons glad to see a no vote returned. But I don’t believe we’ve seen the end of this and we will see the treaty served up again in another form at another referendum yet.

I think it might be a bit of a shock to the Dail (Irish equivalent to Parliament) though as I think many of them assummed a yes was a foregone conclusion. One TD was even going around with the bizzarre message vote yes because otherwise you will regret it - trying to scare people into voting yes with rather histrionic speeches about us never been seen as truly part of Europe again if we did not blah blah blah.

To understand exactly why the treaty is dubious and how much sovreignty it robbed from individuals states you really have to read it in depth.

I was so relieved today. The battle was won but is the war over? Time will tell.

The EU will crumble under the Extreme Socialistic (I want to use another word, but I will leave it out for now) rules it is trying to impose on people. There already have been reports of cracks in the foundation. Expect the threat of sanctions or judicial activism next.

I am also happy that Ireland remains a land free from the evils of abortion. That’s awesome! :extrahappy:

I’d like to give the Irish people who voted against the referendum and defeated it. :tiphat: You certainly didn’t put up with any blarney. However, unfortunately the Socialists, “reformed” Communists, Communists, one-world types will try again. They really don’t care for religion or basic human rights, especially for the smallest human beings(the unborn)

A word of caution to America, it’s already started here. Do you think the powers that be will use a full frontal attack against our rights and protection under our US Constitiution and Bill of Rights? Or, will they try an end run?

It is great news that Ireland has voted NO. I would love to see Ireland leave the EU. I am sick of been ruled by those Godless creatures in the EU. The EU will try it’s best to destroy Ireland. They are pushing for years to make us legalize abortion and bring in Gay marriage. Homosexuality should be made a criminal offense. And Gay people should be thrown into prison if they refuse to be exorcised. Ireland fought long and hard to liberate the country from the Satanic Protestants.


Its a great day for the Irish.

I am delighted that Ireland voted ‘no’ to Lisbon… I’m just curious, since you (and others) have mentioned about the EU trying to force abortion on us, did you not accept the Bishop’s Conference statement in which they assured Catholics that the Treaty would not force Ireland to change its laws on abortion and euthanasia? I was quite disappointed to see certain organisations placing leaflets in churches which basically told Catholics that it would be wrong to vote ‘yes’ because Lisbon would force Ireland to change its position on such issues - this was after the Bishops issued their press statement and after Bishop Michael Smith of Meath told Irish Catholics that it is the Catholic Church in Ireland alone which speaks for the Catholic Church in Ireland.

Anyway, it was actually the ‘yes’ side which convinced me to vote ‘no’! They gave me no convincing arguments - the line they kept spinning was the “Europe has been good to us” one. If that was what we were voting on I think there would have been a resounding yes; but just because something has been good in the past does not mean it is will be good for the future. Also the last scare-tactic which came from the yes people was that renegotiation of the treaty will not be possible. What rubbish. It doesn’t say much about our politicians in Brussels if they are not willing to do all it takes to get the best possible deal foreveryone. In Ireland, I think we know better than most that renegotiation is always an option - how many times over the past two decades did politicians meet in Northern Ireland in ‘last-ditch’ efforts to negotiate a deal?! I think, overall, those who voted against the treaty felt bullied by the majority of politicians who were calling for a yes vote - I found the arrogance of so many of these politicians to be absolutely sickening… And this arrogance continues even after the referendum - the minister for Europe ( I’m not sure if I can name him) had the audacity on television this afternoon to blame the no campaigners for the result - he said that they gave so much misleading information to the electorate that they were confused…

I would like to say one thing. I live in the North of Ireland so we were not involved in the vote but the North of Ireland is strongly against abortion. They have tried to introduce it by the back door with some new legislation and Protestants as well as Catholics have spoke out strongly against it. It has been argued that as Northern Ireland is part of the UK, are laws should all be the same. Many women travel to England and Scotland each year to have abortions and it has been argued that to make things less traumatic for them, it should be legal here. A Protestant MP from a party I can’t stand pointed out that 1 in 4 children in England are aborted which is horrendous. Those who are very much in favour of union with Britain are fighting hard to legislate for themselves on abortion. The other thing is, the vast majority of the population here agree. It must be the only thing in this part of the world we do agree on! I would like to ask one thing though. It has been proposed that women who want to have abortions should have a travel ban to the UK imposed on them. I don’t know if it should go that far as they may just travel to Europe anyway and a lot of politicians who are anti-abortion don’t want to impose this. I would prefer women came to the decision not to have an abortion themselves as opposed to using the force of law. What does anyone else think?

That’s the most bananas version I’ve ever heard of Irish history…

The Bishops were right to a point. The main problem I had was that the Treaty was self-amending without having to go back to the people for approval. Abortion etc. could be brought in at a later stage. If you look at the wording of the amendment itself you’ll see what I mean

Is it safe to say that you are a Commie, EU, Prod loving Fag?:slight_smile:

AJ44, I would like you to read the rules.

I second your analysis, JharekCarnelian… aj44’s portrayal of the EU as being the root of all evil in Irish society is irrational and inaccurate. Do you honestly believe that if we had stayed out of the EU that there would not be people calling for homosexual ‘marriage’ or abortion? Even in good old Catholic Ireland of the 1960’s -and well before we ever joined the EU - there was immorality in Irish society. There was murder, robbery, homosexuality, adultery, young women travelling to England for abortions as is still happening today. I would not say that I’m happy with every change that has come about in Irish society in my lifetime, but I know that much of our economic prosperity has come as a direct result of EU funding, to give but one example of our positive interaction with Europe.

You seem to have quite a skewed view of Irish history if you think that “Ireland fought long and hard to liberate the country from the Satanic Protestants”. Apart from showing a disgusting disrespect for non-Catholics you completely (& very conveniently) ignore that there were many of these “Satanic Protestants” as you call them, which fought for our freedom from British rule - from Wolfe Tone & Robert Emmet to Charles Stewart Parnell are examples which immediately come to mind… You must be very uncomfortable in modern multicultural Ireland which is home to many a Protestant, Jew and Muslim.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit