it is illogical to conclude that God is not Perfect and All Loving because He chose to create human beings that would reject Him.
why is it illogical? for two reasons:
first, it results in the conclusion that not creating human beings to enjoy eternal life with Him is more loving than creating them to enjoy eternal life with Him. it is like saying it is better for no one to have eternal life than for some to have eternal life.
second, it results in the conclusion that God should let those who would reject Him prevent those who would love Him from having eternal life. it is like saying God should have given evil power over Himself.
what kind of nonsensical being would draw those two conclusions and thus not share His eternal life with His creatures?
i believe the erroneous premise comes from a deficit of understanding the meaning of love.