Messianic Judaism

Hi everyone. Can someone explain Messianic Judaism to me and why it is wrong? :shrug::confused:

Holly, from what I’ve gathered Messianic Judaism comes in a couple of varieties. There are, first, Jews who have come to accept Christ and in doing so have embraced a more Evangelical Protestant theology; second, there are some Evangelical Christians who try to incorporate Jewish practices (Sabbath worship and other Jewish holidays) into their lives as Christians. These latter often denigrate and dismiss the teachings of St. Paul because they see him as anti-Jewish; they also tend to be quite anti-Catholic. I think you can see the problems with both versions.

FYI, here is website for the Association of Hebrew Catholics:

Like FCEGM said, there are several different “brands” of Messianic Judaism. I was considering Messianic Judaism a couple years ago, so I know a bit about their general beliefs. Among other things they believe in immersion-only baptism, that Mary was not perpetually virgin, and, most significantly (for us anyway), that the Mosaic Law is still required. They don’t accept the Deuterocanon. They also refer to Jesus as Yeshua. I want to get my hands on Dr. David Stern’s “Jewish Bible,” which is a Messianic Jewish Old and New Testament that uses the original Hebrew names. Mostly because I collect Bible translations like magpies collect shiny objects. :smiley:

Grace-based Messianics usually call themselves Christians, rather than say they practice Messianic Judasim. Messianic Judaism can mean many things. It can mean they just believe a Messiah is coming and they totally reject Jesus as Messiah.

But if one calls himself a Messianic Christian, you know his Messiah is Jesus Christ.

The main problem with some Messianic Christians(as well as other Christians) is that they mingle the Mosiac Covenant Law with the better New Covenant of Grace.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit