Non-Catholic apparitions


#1

I got to wondering:

Catholics have ben blessed with so many approved apparotions of the BVM and many visions, locutions and apparitions of Jesus, and apparitions of other saints as well.

Can other Christian faiths claim the same thing?
Do the Orthodox have visits from our Mother in Heaven?
What about Protestant denominations?

Have Muslims or Jews reported visits by Angels in the common era?

Anyone know anything about this?


#2

obviously, besides the claims of the LDS Church.


#3

I was told by a Baptist friend that any sighting of our Holy Mother, was the work of the devil. She also believed that Mary’s body is buried somewhere in Isreal.

She was taught that ALL apparitions are either devil created or hysteria induced.


#4

Have Muslims or Jews reported visits by Angels in the common era?

Actually, Mary herself has been known to appear to Muslims in the last few decades. This particular sighting was at an Orthodox Church to boot.

touregypt.net/featurestories/vmary.htm


#5

[quote=mkw]I was told by a Baptist friend that any sighting of our Holy Mother, was the work of the devil. She also believed that Mary’s body is buried somewhere in Isreal.

She was taught that ALL apparitions are either devil created or hysteria induced.
[/quote]

Can she show you the grave, if not explain why it has not been found in 2000 years?


#6

[quote=Joe Kelley]Can she show you the grave, if not explain why it has not been found in 2000 years?
[/quote]

Not to get off topic, but this statement struck me, got me wondering, how many burial sites / remains do we know about from the time of Jesus? Any of the 12 Apostles? Any other figures from the time, Cyrus, Barabas, Joseph, St. Paul etc. I believe we know the burial place of St. Peter, possibly of St. Paul. Are they conclusive? What of others? Are most lost?


#7

There was a series of important apparitions of Our Lady at the Zeitoun church in Cairo from 1968-71:

zeitun-eg.net/
zeitun-eg.net/

A Coptic friend of mine saw the phenomenon personally. Apparently, the local Catholic (Roman) bishop believed the apparitions to be authentic.


#8

[quote=Joe Kelley]Can she show you the grave, if not explain why it has not been found in 2000 years?
[/quote]

A tradition of the assumption or dormition is that Mary died and was placed in her tomb, when the apostles showed up to pray and stuff her body was gone. They said it was taken by angels. They know where this tomb is I believe. But there is no body.

I think it was John the Damascene that talked about this. Fr Ambrose posted it on another thread about a month and a half ago.

Here is the link

forums.catholic.com/showthread.php?t=11639&highlight=Assumption


#9

[quote=Dan-Man916]I got to wondering:

Catholics have ben blessed with so many approved apparotions of the BVM and many visions, locutions and apparitions of Jesus, and apparitions of other saints as well.

Can other Christian faiths claim the same thing?
Do the Orthodox have visits from our Mother in Heaven?
What about Protestant denominations?

Have Muslims or Jews reported visits by Angels in the common era?

Anyone know anything about this?
[/quote]

Hi Dan,
As I am not a person with much church history I dont know. I am not even sure what an apparition is.
To my knowledge I have not spoken to or been spoken to by any angels.
But I did go through a period when I could just lie down in bed and get into the zone and see things. I could not ask to see things, things would just come. I imagine that is what happened to people like Leonardi Da Vinci. He probably saw things and then because he was also a talented artist he could draw things. If I could draw, I too could have drawn things. This happened to me in the early 80’s and again for a couple of years late 90’s. I have seen some wonderful things. I used to be able to ask questions as well and get answers. Once I saw this head with a thick head of hacked off red hair. It was being lowered over a high wall on an iron hook. I asked whose head it was and the answer was John’s. This doesn’t come naturally to me now and I dont chase it. But Christ has shown things to me since but “out of the blue” not as a regular " get into the zone" exercise.
As Thailand is a heathen country, there are many spirits around. An acquaintance called me and I visited him this week. He has been in a new house ( renting an older place) for 4 weeks. His 3 year old daughter has to share her toys with a spirit.The daughter has told them the spirit will kill her if she wont share her toys. He was serious. This spirit only talks to the 3 year old. I didnt know what to do. He is not really christian. I said I didnt know any thing about spirits but he should remember the authority in the name Jesus Christ and he should teach his daughter to say it. It is not a subject that scares people away here. Not many, but it is not too uncommon to talk to people who have a personal story to tell about spirits and where they live.
Nearly all pieces of land have a small or larger ( the size of a car) spirit house for the spirit of the land to live in. to appease him for taking and using the land. There is a lot of fortune telling in this land as well and things must be done on the auspicious date, the date being supplied by a monk, who I suppose contacts a spirit.
The chinese are very supersticious and are always consulting the spirits. Living in Christian countries tends to blind us to our blessings.
I hope I haven’t strayed off the subject.
Christ be with youhttp://forums.catholic.com/images/icons/icon7.gif
walk in love
edwinG


#10

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.