Oral & Written Tradition - the Key to the N.T



The Catholic Church Before The New Testament Was Written Down

by Paul Stenhouse, M.S.C., Ph.D


The impression given by ‘bible’ Christians, 'evangelists and others brought up in a non-Catholic view of Christianity, is that the ‘authority’ of the bible is ‘supreme’.

As an ‘evangelical’ writer in the *Sydney Morning Herald * put it some time ago (June 15, 1992) ‘the Bible is not just a source of knowledge of God, but it is the source — the only source’.

The same author went on to say: ‘The view of Martin Luther and his modern-day reformed evangelical counterparts is that there is only one reliable source of knowledge of God: the Bible’.

Without mentioning the Catholic Church the author then goes on to talk about a so-called liberal view, also centuries old and still very much found today within certain church circles (which) suggests that there are potentially four valid grounds for knowledge of God and his dealings with us, namely reason, tradition, experience, as well as revelation.’

The author categorises Catholic views on the important role of Reason and Tradition in the religious quest, as liberal,’ implying that the fundamentalist ‘evangelical’ view is ‘conservative’.

***The ‘Ancient’ Christian Faith was Catholic * **

The evangelical view dates from the time of Martin Luther, and is, indeed, 450 years old. But the author neglects to say (perhaps he doesn’t know) that the Catholic view from which Luther sprang and which nurtured him, is 2,000 years old and dates from Apostolic times. The Catholic ‘view’ is not ‘also centuries old.’ It is, if the truth be told, the *ancient * Christian view.

Well, was Martin Luther *really * returning to the early days of Christianity with his teaching that the scriptures are the only source of knowledge of God, or was he reacting to a situation in which, having rejected the authority of the Pope, and abandoned the Catholic Church, he had to find another ‘authority’ that could support his views … as it was later on to support myriad other views, often conflicting and contradictory?

To seek an answer to these questions we have to return to the early centuries and look at the beginnings of Christianity. Let us consider specifically the relationship of the infant Catholic Church to the New Testament — the Christian sacred writings — as distinct from the Jewish sacred writings that are called the Old Testament. And let us see especially the role these Christian scriptures played in the formative early years of the Church.

Read the complete article HERE

  1. How did the Bible get here?

  2. Why did the Church compile all the different books into a single volume we call the Bible?

Having the answers to these questions will help refute
*]bible alone theory
*]self-attesting of scripture
*]the false dichotomy of tradition v.s.scripture
[/list]Knowing well the answers will help support
*]the authority of the Church
*]the role of Tradition
*]the Church’s reverence for Scripture
*]the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass
[/list]I’ll give my answers to these 2 questions later;)

Excellent article, Sean.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.