Protestant said praying to Mary isn’t in the bible


The Jews didn’t keep the New Testament either. What’s his point?

And which Jews had the authority to determine what was and what wasn’t sacred scripture? Because the Pharisees held to one list and the Sadducees and Essenes also had their own list. So there was no Jewish agreement on what was and what wasn’t sacred scripture.

I’m still waiting for him to tell us how he knows what is and what isn’t sacred scripture. Can’t use the Jews as reference because they couldn’t agree among each other.


Does he believe in the Trinity? Because that’s not mentioned in scripture either. Perhaps he doesn’t realize that the purpose of scripture is to teach concepts, not limit vocabulary.


so he is currently in a pure and sinless state of existence?


well Jesus gave the authority to Peter and his successors, what’s your authority ?who are you? who gave your authority?

A pastor is appointed for all Christians Peter and his successors the Pope

John 21: 15-17 - Jesus, seeing Peter, asked him three times : "Simon, Son of John, do you love me more than these?" And three times Peter answered Him: "Yes, Lord, you know that I love you." Jesus told Him three times: "Feed my sheep."

  • My ‘sheep’ means all the disciples of Jesus,
  • Feed means look after them.
  • Peter is the first pastor - Pastor for all the Christians in the world. Pope means a loving father.
  • This appointment is from Jesus Himself.

What happens if one is not subject to those appointed by God?

Romans 13: 1-2 - Let every person be subject to the governing authorities; for there is no authority except from God; and more authorities that exist have been instituted by God; Therefore whoever resists authority resists what God has appointed and those who resist will incur judgement.

  • Since Jesus in saying "Feed my sheep" has given authority to Peter over all his sheep. All sheep belonging to Jesus should be obedient to this authority.

Samuel 15:22 - Has the Lord as great a delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices as in obeying the voice of the Lord?

  • Surely to obey is better than sacrifice; and to heed is better than the fat of rams.

Authority given to the Church by Jesus

Mathew 16: 19 - I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven and whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.

  • Some misuse this authority given by Jesus. While others do not use it at all. But there are some who use this authority for the spread of the Church and God’s kingdom. Should we not be among these ones?

Jesus selected 12 disciples and gave them authority

Mathew 10:1 - Jesus summoned his twelve disciples and gave them authority over unclean spirits to cast them out, and to cure every disease and every sickness.

  • One must be selected by God and remain obedient to the Church; There is no truth in self-declared church and leadership.

that’s your personal authority ,you have no authority to do that. Finally Only The Catholic Church has the sole right to interpret the scriptures and to correct errors Acts 20:28 Keep watch over yourselves and over all the flock, of which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to shepherd the church of God that he obtained with the blood of his own Son.


Yes, the New Testament is based on the Catholic faith. The New Testament was written by Catholics for Catholics.

Right, it is based on Catholic understanding of scripture.


Much of it was actually written for Jews, though Jews rejected it. Catholics didn’t exist in the first century.

The Christian Bible was written for everyone, though most of the world does not adhere to it, e.g., Jews, Buddhists, Muslims, etc.


is intercessory prayer in the Bible?


The Christian bible is not based on a Catholic understanding. That’s ludicrous. The Catholic religion developed out of Catholic theologians’ understanding of the Christian bible. The book came first. And not all of your theologians are in agreement.


Not through Mary.


Yes they did. The Catholic church is one and the same as the Church established by Christ in the first century. The name “Catholic” arose from Christianity’s universality.


saying there were no Catholics in the first century is the same as saying there were no Christians in the first century. So that statement is wrong. The first Christians were Catholics

The Christian New Testament was written for the faithful who were already believers. It was not written to evangelize non-believers.


the church came first… the book says so.


that wasn’t the question. If intercessory prayer is in the Bible then it is biblical regardless of who you ask to intercede for you.


Yes, groups of Christians gathered, but no Catholic church existed as an hierarchical entity as it does today. Wherever the worshippers of Christ were, they were just called “Christians.” Some Eastern Orthodox Catholics claim they were first.


What do you think?


Actually - no they weren’t called Christians at all. It was just called “The Church”.

The Catholic church today and the Church founded by Christ is one and the same.


Not exactly.


Yes, exactly. One and the same.


yes, they most definitely did have a hierarchical entity, they knew who their bishop was and they knew who laid hands on their bishop with authority. Christians/Catholics it has the same meaning. Yes, the Catholics were in the East before being established in the West. They were still Catholics.

You are not seeing that the acorn and the oak tree are the same plant.


that praying to Mary to intercede for you is in the Bible.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit