Question concerning heresy


I found this on another thread:

Originally Posted by GAssisi
Do they really have any good basis for considering Catholics heretics? I have not seen any.

Originally Posted by Fr. Ambrose
Alas, creating a de fide dogma (sorry for the tautology) that one bishop is personally infallible when teaching on matters of faith and morals is a heresy.


It seems to me that Fr. Ambrose is stating the Orthodox view of the papacy. What is the truth or untruth of the answer to the question?



Please see the responses that Fr. A’s statement has garnered in the original “Orthodox and Catholic for Salival” thread in the “Non-Catholics” Forum.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit