I recently purchased all of Karl Keating’s books. As I looked up Mr. Keating’s books, I noticed several critiques to Catholicism and Fundamentalism. There two books by Robert Zins Romanism: The Relentless Roman Catholic Assault on the Gospel of Jesus Christ and Formidable Truth: A Vindication of Lorainne Boettner which are suppossed to be rebuttals to Mr. Keating’s book. The main claims are:
Karl Keating quoted scripture out of context.
Karl Keating misquoted Lorainne Boettner
Karl Keating relies on “Church Fathers” like Irenaus, Origen, Tertulian, and Justin Martyr who supported heretical views.
There is also a book Church of Rome at the Bar of History by William David Webster which claims that the “Roman” Church’s reliance on History is unfounded.
Has anyone ever heard about or read these works? How accurate are they? I’m a young Catholic who wants to be informed. Thank you.