Should my daughter be an altar server?


#1

I am in a dilemma and I hope that you can help me. I have become increasingly alarmed at the feminism of the Church. I am thinking of pulling my daughter from the altar servers in my parish. The reason is the feminization of the Church that I alluded to above. I was wondering what the Church has said regarding altar girls. It used to be that the Church received vocations from altar boys. Could this be one of the reasons why vocations are lacking? No man in his right mind would want to trade his God-given masculinity to become a feminized cleric.

Spirituality is many times seen as a woman’s domain and I for one am tired of it. Think of all of the “touchy-feely” sermons you have heard and I will bet you that you could not remember the last sermon you may have heard on hell, purgatory, or the last things. Boys are no longer serving on the altar. Please know that I have the highest respect and admiriation for women and consider them not only my equals but, in many instances, my betters. In your reply please send links to actual documents if possible.


#2

In 1994 the Church allowed bishops to give permission for girls and women to be altar servers within their dioceses. If a bishop of a local diocese allows the practice, parents may choose to allow their daughters to be altar servers. It is also within the rights of a parent to not allow his daughters to be altar servers. The Church does indeed still very much recommend that boys should serve at the altar:

It is altogether laudable to maintain the noble custom by which boys or youths, customarily termed servers, provide service of the altar after the manner of acolytes, and receive catechesis regarding their function in accordance with their power of comprehension. Nor should it be forgotten that a great number of sacred ministers over the course of the centuries have come from among boys such as these. … Girls or women may also be admitted to this service of the altar, at the discretion of the diocesan bishop and in observance of the established norms (Redemptionis Sacramentum 47).

That said, it seems that you have already given your daughter permission to be an altar server and are considering revoking that permission based upon a personal ideology. It is within your rights as a parent to do so. Could it be though that you could have thought through your position more carefully before giving permission? Would it be just to your daughter to penalize her now for a neglect to do so (particularly since the Church itself has no problem with your daughter’s altar service)?

Finally, what is the situation at your local parish? Do boys now serve at the altar? If you remove your daughter from the program, is there a likelihood that she will be replaced by a boy or will she likely be replaced by another girl? If she is likely to be replaced by another girl, what would be the point of removing her from the program?

Whatever you decide to do for your daughter, it seems to me that if a feminization of parish life bothers you, then perhaps you should consider your own level of commitment in parish life and ask yourself if there is more that you can do. Options for service include becoming a lector, an extraordinary minister of holy Communion, an usher, a catechist, or a parish leader. Perhaps your involvement in parish life may inspire other men to follow your example. When problems like this crop up, our first thought ought to be given to what we ourselves can do to make a difference. After that is done, then it makes sense to consider what we can ask our families to do to pitch in as well.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.