Sin and Taxes


I was hoping someone could settle a moral quandary that has come up in my life recently. I'm a young person, in my early 20s, still in college, and I have had summer jobs and such, and I am recently becoming acquainted with intricacies of the tax law that I was previously ignorant of. I have never personally done my taxes, that is something my parents have aided me with by using their accountant to take care of what I owe based off of my summer work. But I've been completely honest in this regard for as long as I've been working.

I have recently learned that my state imposes a "use tax" where if you purchase things out of state and sales tax is not collected (even over the internet) then you have to pay a "use tax" and since this can be complicated for you to calculate, my state offers estimates you can take advantage of and it only amounts to $8 a year (for 2013 at least) in my income bracket. Having just found this out it has occurred to me that I should have paid this tax for the past 3 years at least as well. So I'm basically wondering what I have to do in this regard, I intend to pay it this year since tax season is not over yet, but what about the previous years? Should I just let it go? I personally don't even have access to the documents I would need to report these back use taxes, and obtaining them would most likely require putting a family friend (the accountant) through a great deal of trouble on my behalf (he does our taxes for free) to pour over my information for a sum of money that is rather insignificant.

Moreover, even if I did have the documents and was able to report these back taxes, I may very well be hit with penalties for who knows how much. And to me, this would be extremely unfair especially considering this is a tax that basically no one pays (not saying it's right, but it would be unfair to punish the one person who tries to be honest while letting others off the hook) and it is something I was legitimately ignorant of, I don't know how the state government can expect a teenager to know these minute intricacies of the tax code who is now in his early 20s and still in school. But then again, the saying "ignorance of the law is no excuse" comes to mind.

This wouldn't be such a big issue in my mind, except that I've been taught that we have a moral obligation to obey the civil law, and if I don't report these back taxes am I not in a perpetual state of breaking the law for as long as I do not comply with it? :shrug: But on the other hand, is there a moral/legal obligation to correct what these things amount to, which are honest mistakes? I don't know and was hoping for some answers.


I’d say that you should probably let it go. If the state wants to pursue insignificant tax errors made several years ago then that’s there prerogative, but I don’t think that you have such an obligation.


now this post is funny, you have to appreciate this broad comparison of this concern for not paying taxes, when its recognized,, the US government and the current most failed generation ever in all of world history has not payed $17,000,000,000,000 in taxes it now OWES!

The current most failed generation has not payed this tax bill, a huge sin to thrust this debt for which thier is nothing to show for and extend to the generations to come, but is being enslaved with a debt of 17trillion dollars...

now that is a much better example of a Sin, to enslave the generations in debt, and to teach them not prudence, discipline, or self sacrific, but greed and gluttony..
Has not the most failed generation ever in world history committed a huge sin?
Has not the most failed generation ever in world history commited a great attrocity against the generations to come in setting a dispicable example of lack of responsibility and concern for the generations to come..

Voting for obama was a huge sin, that we see proven more so every day, but also for those that voted for the wars of the rich on the poor that created this great debt...

see, its a fact that government and religion must go hand in hand, for religion represents morality and intergrity, to which calls for a government to be under Gods laws to be moral and be of that intergrity God calls us to.. Godless government strips away peoples freedom, and as today makes them mere slaves of debt, debt created by unjustified wars... of revenge..


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit