Stole before i came to God

Hello i am a new Christian. I stole before i came to God and wanted to know if i should give money back to the stores i stole from like Wal-Mart and other stores or should i just ask God for forgiveness and let it be?


I also shoplifted in the past. When I confessed this old sin to my priest, he advised me the best way to make restitution is to give money in charity.

I accidentally stole from a store before. I had an item mailed to my home. I called a week later when it hadn’t arrived. They sent the item again. When it arrived my husband said 'Weird. We just got a box from these people last week. I didn’t know what to do with it, so I put it in the basement.'
So I drove up to the store with the second package and explained the whole thing.
Then I went shopping around. Half an hour later she was still on the phone with the warehouse figuring out how to get this back to the warehouse since she couldn’t add it to her own inventory.
Oy vey.
Give an equal amount to charity or send a check to the company for the amount. I wouldn’t explain, just pop a check in the mail, send it to headquarters with a note that says ‘This belongs to you’ and leave it at that.
Hopefully their accountants won’t him and haw over it too much and just stick it in misc revenue or something like that.

Hi, CupOfMilk. I noticed that this problem is still weighing on your mind. (Over the past nine months or so, you have started several threads about sins committed before you became Christian.)

I don’t know whether you are Catholic, or whether you belong to a Protestant denomination. One of the greatest treasures we have in the Catholic Church is the Sacrament of Reconciliation (also called Penance or Confession) in which we are assured of God’s forgiveness, and the priest can give us good advice on how to deal with things that plague us from our past.

Are you Catholic? (Have you been fully initiated into the Catholic Church by Catholic baptism or by being formally received into the Catholic Church as an adult?) If so, I highly recommend that you go to confession to “wipe the slate clean” of all these things that are nagging at your conscience.

If you are not Catholic, perhaps this is God’s way of calling you to the Catholic Church, where you can receive the Sacrament of Reconciliation that assures you of His forgiveness. The problem with your idea to “just ask God for forgiveness and let it be” is that, outside the Sacrament that God has given us as the ordinary means to obtain His forgiveness, we can never be sure that we are truly forgiven. When we go to confession and the priest, acting in the person of Christ, speaks the words of absolution (forgiveness), we can be absolutely certain we are forgiven, because Jesus Himself said so in speaking to the apostles, the predecessors of today’s Catholic bishops and priests: “Whose sins you forgive, they are forgiven them.”

So if you are not Catholic, pray to the Holy Spirit to lead you to the Church Jesus founded, and talk to a Catholic priest about how to make it happen.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit