Strange claims about the Papacy

I saw the following posted on a blog (who is not Catholic) and I was wondering if someone would care to comment:

Upon Columbus’ “discovery” of the New World, the Pope proclaimed that, as “king of heaven and of earth and of the lower regions” (as the triple tiara signifies) and “governor of the world”, he actually had owned the Americas all the while, and the Natives had been living on his land. They now needed to pay rent. This is the reason that Spanish soldiers engaged in the brutality that they did in order to obtain their treasures from their mines- because they were collecting rent for the Pope. 90% of the gold obtained went to the Pope; the other 10% went to the ruling king. Incidentally, not once was a ship carrying the Pope’s gold attacked by pirates; they only attacked vessels carrying payment for the king. (Isn’t it interesting that the skull and crossbones is the flag of the Jesuit Order, as well?)

So how much of this could be true?


Reas this:

[quote=Genesis315]Reas this:

That letter pretty much refutes the said blog that was posted here :smiley:

Hi Jason, simply ask him for his proof,

Treaty of Tordesillas

Upon returning to Spain in 1493 after his first voyage, Christopher Columbus contacted Pope Alexander VI (a Spaniard by birth) to report his discoveries. Acting as the great European arbiter of the day, the pope then issued a bull (decree) that divided the New World lands between Spain and Portugal by establishing a north-south line of demarcation 100 leagues* west of the Cape Verde Islands. Undiscovered non-Christian lands to the west of the line were to be Spanish possessions and those to the east belonged to Portugal.

News of this decision was not warmly greeted by the Portuguese, who argued that previous agreements conflicted with the pope’s decision.

In the spring of 1494, representatives of Spain and Portugal met in the Spanish town of Tordesillas and negotiated a mutually satisfactory solution to their dispute. The line of demarcation was relocated to a position 370 leagues west of the Cape Verde Islands. (It was impossible during this age to determine precisely the impact of this agreement on account of the nagging difficulty of establishing longitude accurately.) However, Portugal emerged with an enhanced position by gaining a larger portion of South America (Brazil). Even with this modification, Spain had gained control (on paper) of most of the New World.

The pope granted his official recognition of this agreement in 1506. Spain and Portugal, with a few exceptions, remained loyal to the terms of the treaty; the Portuguese would expand deep into Brazil beyond the demarcation line, but Spain did not object. The natives of these regions, needless to say, were not consulted about the assignment of their homelands to others and competing powers in Europe totally ignored the line.

For years following 1494, the Spanish lamented their consent to the treaty, convinced that they had received the short end of the stick. Their initial discoveries in the New World yielded little mineral wealth, but much disease and discomfort. Their evaluation of this bargain with Portugal changed dramatically in the 1520s as the riches from Aztec Mexico began to be exploited.

In the Treaty of Zaragoza (1529), the demarcation line was extended through both poles and encompassed the entire world.

*A league is the equivalent of three nautical miles. A nautical mile (6,076 feet) is about 15 percent longer than a statute mile (5,280 feet). The Tordesillas line was located approximately 1,270 statute miles west of the Cape Verde Islands.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit