In my 25 years as a very active Evangelical I read many of these books. There are some incredible books on this list. I only wish I had taken the time back in the day to read people like St. Augustine, St. Clement, St. Irenaeus, The Desert Fathers, and St. Aquinas. It is important to be well-rounded and be mindful of the fact that a lot happened in Christianity before 1517.
Information is never a bad thing. I hope we can agree, at least, on that.