The U.S. military has a problem with atheists

Yahoo! News:

The U.S. military has a problem with atheists

Apparently, the Marine Corps thinks a “lack or loss of spiritual faith” could be dangerousWhen an active-duty Marine was given a Marine Corps training document describing “potential risk indicators” commanders should look for to prevent loss of life among service members, he found one checkbox that didn’t seem to fit. Among warning signs like substance abuse and prior suicide attempts was “lack or loss of spiritual faith.”

Concerned that this was a discriminatory policy, the Marine notified the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF), a nonprofit dedicated to keeping religion separate from the U.S. military. The organization, which told me that it plans to sue the U.S. Marines unless the government backs off this policy, says this is the military’s latest effort to discriminate against service members who don’t believe in God.

Advocates for the policy say the military is simply doing everything it can to promote emotional well-being among troops, especially in the face of its growing suicide epidemic. (Last year, the U.S. military saw more active duty soldiers commit suicide than die in combat — 48 of them Marines.)

“The whole concept of judging service members based on their spirituality is completely unconstitutional,” says Mikey Weinstein, a former Air Force officer and founder and president of MRFF. “This country was founded on a very critical principle — the founding framers looked at the horrors that occurred throughout history by mixing religion and war, and they said, we’re going to separate church and state. And that means they cannot test for religion in the military.”

Qy: would the MRFF care if “lack or loss of faith” were proven to be a risk factor for suicide?

Perhaps a reasonable compromise would be to adjust the policy so that it doesn’t suggest that an atheist is automatically at risk of suicide or shooting spree behaviors, but instead modify the language to “sudden and/or traumatic” loss of faith.

Would seem to meet the intent without being innately insulting to atheists.

I think the actual intent is to indentify personell that are at risk for suicide. If would appear the MRFF is more concerned with throwing its weight araound than the lives of Marines.

Precisely. So fight their unreasonableness with charity and reason. Agree to modify the language so that it applies to sudden or traumatic loss of faith, not the lifelong Christopher Hitchens fans. Take their ammo away.

Why put lives at risk to mollify someone’s unreasonableness?


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit