The vocation crisis is not limited to the priesthood

Right now, it feels like the whole notion of “vocations” to anything is taking a beating.

The news out of Pittsburgh is gut-wrenching for anyone who loves the Catholic Church. Two-thirds of the parishes, many of them beloved by generations, gone within five years. Why? Declining numbers of priests, says the bishop. So Pittsburgh has to retrench and deal with the new reality. A Church in decline, a Church in retreat, a Church where God has mysteriously ceased to call young people to the priesthood. Or to religious life. Or, if you look at the statistics, even to lifelong, fruitful, marriages. There are just no vocations to anything out there anymore. We have to close churches, there is no other way.

I hear this lament too often from people involved in the Church. It seems to be an accepted fact that God no longer calls people, that the Holy Spirit has abandoned us, and that slowly, and surely, the gates of Hell are prevailing against the Catholic Church.

But this assertion doesn’t even make sense. If God lied about knowing people and calling them by name, if Jesus lied about the gates of hell, if the Holy Spirit is no longer Paraclete but apo clete, than why are we keeping any churches open at all? Shouldn’t we just shut the whole operation down and sleep in on Sunday mornings?

It’s true. We’re in a vocations crisis. Priestly vocations may have been the bellwether, but it’s not because clergy can’t marry. Marriage is in decline too. Out-of-wedlock childbearing, broken families, kids who drift vocation-less for decades, these are all common now, even among people who were raised Catholic. The problem with this approach is that God has not stopped calling us. It’s that we’ve become unable, or unwilling, to listen. Or perhaps, thanks to our distracted world of iPhones and social media, we’ve completely drowned God out with noise. We need to encourage people away from that noise, and teach them how to hear that soft, still voice.

Look around: the parishes, youth groups, and dioceses that are “vocations powerhouses” emphasize time for quiet prayer and adoration. They encourage kids to praise God, to serve their neighbors, and to think and pray and ask about their vocation. The whole community comes together to encourage discernment. Vocations directors, seminarians, religious and married couples aren’t too shy to talk about their vocations and how they’ve seen God leading them in their own lives.

When vocations are important to a diocese, and actively pursued, God sends vocations. And not “just enough vocations to get by.” Jesus showed us again and again in the Gospels that when he gives, he gives superabundantly…

1 Like

O Holy Spirit! Spirit of wisdom and divine love! Impart Your knowledge, understanding, and counsel to youth that they may know the vocation wherein they can best serve God. Give them courage and strength to follow God’s holy will. Guide their uncertain steps, strengthen their resolutions, shield their chastity, fashion their minds, conquer their hearts, and lead them to the vineyards where they will labor in God’s holy service. Amen. :blue_heart:


Let us form Rosary groups wherever and however possible, and flood the adoration times with wall to wall people in the pews! We need much prayer and sacrifices to make change possible!

I pray for them DAILY!

How true, many “Vocations” are in decline, Fatherhood, Motherhood, Marriage, Teaching. All important Vocations for a healthy society.
Priesthood comes forth from a Christian family. Most of the time, GOD can indeed bring a priest from a rock if HE wished to. But it should be up to us to feed the Church with able and willing men who wished to become Jesus’s priests.
We need to pray every day for all these vocations that the Holy Spirit grant us the miracle of bringing forth a renewed society for the well being of all.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 14 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit