I would go in your e-mail settings, and click on all of the boxes if you want to do that.
If you click on all of them, then you will get notified any time that someone replies to you, quotes you, and so on.
I just have mine set so that I get a notice if someone sends me a message. That is the only box that I have checked off, for example.
In your drop-down menu box, you can decide how you want to set that particular one–always, never, etc.
Then for any of these changes to take effect, you want to click on the “save changes” button, and then refresh/reload your browser page/window, and/or restart your computer, too, just to make sure that everything takes effect, just like I explained to Fr. David in my post to him.
In the event that you’re still having problems, I would also contact the CA Webmaster.
God bless you both.
I’m still finding my way around too, after a few weeks of poking around.