US bishops' relief agency defends alliance with aid organization

Washington D.C., Jul 21, 2012 / 05:02 pm (CNA).- Catholic Relief Services, the official overseas relief agency for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, says that it worked with a leading Catholic bioethics group in conducting careful reviews to ensure that its funding decisions were in alignment with Church teaching.

“Catholic Relief Services, in communion with the Church, strictly upholds Catholic moral teaching,” the organization said.

“All of the CRS programs and all of the funds used by CRS are entirely consistent with Church teaching.”

In a statement provided to CNA, the group responded to recent concerns raised about its funding of CARE, an international humanitarian organization that provides relief to the needy in developing nations but also offers contraception and early abortion-inducing drugs.
Catholic Relief Services said that it has “always has taken very seriously decisions we make about the groups with which we collaborate or form partnerships to ensure that we are not violating the Church teachings.”

The agency stressed that it promotes “abstinence and Natural Family Planning as embraced by the Church” and reiterated that it does not “fund, support or participate in any programming or advocacy that is not in line with Church teaching, including artificial birth control.”

The organization said that concerns over CARE had previously been raised. In response, it teamed with Dr. John Haas of the National Catholic Bioethics Center to undertake “a thorough review” of all its partnerships.

The resulting report determined that the activities being reviewed did not “suggest support of or involvement in immoral activities” and that there was “no material cooperation with evil.”

In addition, it found that the funding from Catholic Relief Services was not “fungible,” meaning that there was “little to no risk” of the grant money being used for purposes beyond those listed in the grant request or freeing up money for immoral purposes within the receiving organizations.

The National Catholic Bioethics Center did, however, determine that “there could be a risk of controversy or scandal over such partnerships if people become confused and wrongly assume that CRS was endorsing a partner’s position on other issues.”

To prevent such a misunderstanding, Catholic Relief Services worked with the bioethics groups and the bishops to make their adherence to Church teaching clear through their mission statement and communications.

“Faithfulness to Church teaching always has been and always will be our policy,” the group emphasized.

So let me see if I have this right. The USCCB appears to oppose the HHS mandate, (being faithful to church teaching and all that,) but yet sees no contradiction in funding a group that could use the money for what amounts to the same purpose!



Okay, I’m sorry if I seem like a bigot, but contraception is against the Churches teaching, so how are they remaining faithful at this point???

Michael Voris, host of the Vortex on Church Militant TV, was wondering the same thing. He had a special “Vortex” episode on Saturday July 21 on this very subject. You can go to to view this special episode.

there is a thread going regarding this already.

Nope. :nope:

More to it than that.

Because they have not given any money to programs that go against Catholic teaching . They have only given to programs that provide water and sanitation, food and nutrition. They also promote abstinence and natural family planning. it seems CARE was not totally forthcoming regarding John Hass’s advice

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit