What are the views of the Holy Orthodox Church on RCC approved Marian Apparitions?


#1

I know the Orthodox Church has a great devotion to Mary and was just wondering what the views are on apparitions such as Lourdes...Fatima...Locke...etc. Since these have been approved as worthy of belief by the Catholic Church does the Orthodox Church lend them any credence. If not then why not? I do not want to start any kind of battle between our two churches if the answer is no...I'm just curious.


#2

[quote="adoglover1956, post:1, topic:274549"]
I know the Orthodox Church has a great devotion to Mary and was just wondering what the views are on apparitions such as Lourdes...Fatima...Locke...etc. Since these have been approved as worthy of belief by the Catholic Church does the Orthodox Church lend them any credence. If not then why not? I do not want to start any kind of battle between our two churches if the answer is no...I'm just curious.

[/quote]

I promised to keep away from threads threatening to detonate potential bombs between the Orthodox and Catholics...... it seems I was not the only one! :p

ZERO respondents in 37 hours and 230 lurkers? Wow!!! Methinks Lent is doing some good to many CAF members! :D


#3

Just a quick reply.

The Roman Catholic church is not orthodox, therefore any approvals the Vatican might give to anything have no authority.

Traditionally the Orthodox take a dim view of speaking apparitions and messages from beyond, and I personally feel the same way. This would most especially be the case for something that erupts from outside the church.


#4

[quote="Hesychios, post:3, topic:274549"]
Just a quick reply.

The Roman Catholic church is not orthodox, therefore any approvals the Vatican might give to anything have no authority.

Traditionally the Orthodox take a dim view of speaking apparitions and messages from beyond, and I personally feel the same way. This would most especially be the case for something that erupts from outside the church.

[/quote]

Thank you! That's all I was looking for.

God bless.

Mods may feel free to close the thread if they wish. My intent was never to start a war.


#5

I know this is unwanted and unasked for but I had a thought...Jesus warned us
in the last days about so called appearances of Him and to beware of them..That would make me wonder about any appearance like that especially with some of the tings happening today..


#6

[quote="SmallCcatholic, post:5, topic:274549"]
I know this is unwanted and unasked for but I had a thought...Jesus warned us
in the last days about so called appearances of Him and to beware of them..That would make me wonder about any appearance like that especially with some of the tings happening today..

[/quote]

But in Marian apparitions Mary always points people toward her Son. In any case those are private revelations and not bound on anybody to believe...Catholic or not. :)


#7

[quote="adoglover1956, post:6, topic:274549"]
But in Marian apparitions Mary always points people toward her Son. In any case those are private revelations and not bound on anybody to believe...Catholic or not. :)

[/quote]

That may be but there are some that are way over the top. Going crazy over stains and the like..Seems Mary is the one lifted up in place of Jesus..The following after is the scary part..If Jesus warned that about Himself wouldn't it even be more so apply to those apart from the Trinity...We do know the will be two end time witnesses wiil
appear in Jerusalem..


#8

[quote="Marybeloved, post:2, topic:274549"]
I promised to keep away from threads threatening to detonate potential bombs between the Orthodox and Catholics...... it seems I was not the only one! :p

ZERO respondents in 37 hours and 230 lurkers? Wow!!! Methinks Lent is doing some good to many CAF members! :D

[/quote]

After receiving a pm from the OP, I feel the need to clarify this post of mine.

@OP
I never intended to imply that you were intentionally setting up a war. The intention is never there, in such threads, in my experience. But if you read such threads on this forum in the recent past, that's where it generally leads. I didn't mean to make "hits" at you or this thread or this topic- far from it. That's just the nature of Orthodox-Catholic dialogues on internet forums, in my (short) experience and believe me I really thought I was making light of the whole thing. I only meant that many people who have gotten embroiled in them in the past (like me) out of no such intention, must have chosen to avoid it for the very reasons you mentioned in your message to me. It's nothing at all to do with you personally, or even this thread in particular. I'm really sorry you were offended and I state here, for the avoidance of doubt, that I do NOT believe that you were doing anything here but posing a sincere question.

Peace.


#9

[quote="Marybeloved, post:8, topic:274549"]
Aftera pm, I feel the need to clarify this post of mine.

@OP
I never intended to imply that you were intentionally setting up a war. The intention is never there, in such threads, in my experience. But if you read such threads on this forum in the recent past, that's where it generally leads. I didn't mean to make "hits" at you or this thread or this topic- far from it. That's just the nature of Orthodox-Catholic dialogues on internet forums, in my (short) experience and believe me I really thought I was making light of it. I only meant that many people who have gotten embroiled in them in the past (like me) out of no such intention, must have chosen to avoid it for the very reasons you mentioned in your message to me. It's nothing at all to do with you personally, or even this thread inparticular. I'm really sorry you got offended and I state here, for the avoidance of doubt, that I do NOT believe that you were doing anything here but posing a sincere question.

Peace.

[/quote]

Dear Mary...I was not offended. I feared that my thread was offensive to you! :)


#10

[quote="SmallCcatholic, post:5, topic:274549"]
I know this is unwanted and unasked for but I had a thought...Jesus warned us
in the last days about so called appearances of Him and to beware of them..That would make me wonder about any appearance like that especially with some of the tings happening today..

[/quote]

Wouldn't Jesus speaking to Paul on the road to Damascus and Him walking and eating with the disciples on the road to Emmaus be Apparitions?


#11

[quote="adoglover1956, post:9, topic:274549"]
Dear Mary...I was not offended. I feared that my thread was offensive to you! :)

[/quote]

Not at all! Man, I seriously need to work on my joking-on-line skills...:D


#12

[quote="Qwikness, post:10, topic:274549"]
Wouldn't Jesus speaking to Paul on the road to Damascus and Him walking and eating with the disciples on the road to Emmaus be Apparitions?

[/quote]

Yes but that was then and this is now..I have no problem as to what He did but if he warned us about appearances in the end times and the strong deception that has and will happen..


#13

I am finishing work with a devout Greek Orthodox family, and was very impressed with their church calendar of having Wednesdays and Fridays as days of fasting. I wish our former disicplines would return....meatless Friday's...and may be we have more fasting.

Christ said to do penance for the remission of our sins, or we likewise will perish.

The West is not the East.

The family and I see the theological differences, and frankly, we see them as more cultural than theological.

It is good not to follow apparitions.

But I did go to Fatima, because I was in Portugal to learn the language and then go overseas. My roommate lived near Leiria and the family wanted me to go to there.

Mary appeared at Fatima right before the Bolshevik revolutoin, May 13. That is the same day the Holy Father John Paul II was almost assassinated in 1982.

Mary told the children to pray the rosary every day,to pray for the conversion of Russia who would spread many errors in the world....errors that we can see today in American politics and class warfare, to do penance, to know that most people go to hell for the sins of the flesh than any other, to spend time before the Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. She warned that if people did not listen to her request, there would be a second war, worse that would be proceeded by a strange light in the sky.

Days before the Nazi invasion of Poland, an aurora borealis appeared over Europe. Communism was at work liquidating millions of its own people.

At the end of WWII, 7 or 8 German Jesuits had survived the atomic bomb in Japan. Over 200 scientists through the years examined them, and they had no trace of radiation. The two atomic bombs came between the Transfiguration of Our Lord to the Assumption of Mary, her glorious assumption into heaven.

It is said the devout Catholic Japanese who died by the bomb, were likewise gloriously taken to the Lord, so faithful for hundreds of years to the Catholic faith. They went underground for 200 years. They had a prophecy that they could finally come out when...a Catholic Church was built that had the name of Mary...the priest was celibate...this a Latin rite discipline...and that the church would be faithful to Rome. A few came to St. Marys to a Catholic priest faithful to Rome 200 years later.

The Latin rite Church was founded by St. Peter. St. Paul died in Rome. The Catholic faith is apostolic. The Orthodox Church is founded by 11 of the 12 apostles. St. Peter had previously stayed in Rome.

The Roman Catholic Church is not heretical but founded by Jesus Christ through the primacy of Peter. The Latin and Orthodox were one.

When I was coming into the Greek home a few nights later, I asked the woman I was replacing her take of the home, with all the icons of Theotokos, of Christ, and others of saints. Her simple reply was that she was a Christian and these people were Mary worshppers..

I said I was a Christian, a Catholic, we were like Orthodox and we have had these kinds of practices for 2000 years.

I am going to begin to renew Our Lady of F atima's later requestion....that the First Five Saturday's be consecutively attended at Mass as reparation to all that is false towards Mary.


#14

I cant speak for the EO churches, but from what I know about the EO churches, they are not opposed to Apparitions.

They recognize the communion of the Saints, and the Mystical body of Christ, and from what I have read, they have had Apparitions recognized.

I don't know if they are like the Catholic Apparitions, in the manner of being a non-required belief that the individual can hold, or not. Someone from the EO church would have to shed some light on that.

Here are a few, I got off an EO forum

  • **The visitation of the Mother of God with St John the Evangelist and Apostle Peter to St Sergius of Radonezh and his disciple Micah.

    • The appearance of the Mother of God to St Dimitri Donskoy. The event is recorded in the icon of the Mother of God Bogolyubskaya.
    • The appearance of the Mother of God at the church at Blachernae - the origin of the feast of the Holy Protection of the Mother of God.
    • The appearance of Christ and the Virgin to the fathers of the First Ecumenical Council, which led to the restoration of St Nicholas of Myra as bishop, after he had been ejected from the council and stripped of his episcopal rank for assaulting Arius.

The Apparition of The Theotokos, St John and others to St. Seraphim of Sarov**


#15

Thanks, OneManGang....for input...yes, I thought the Orthodox had their approved apparitions and it was said that Mary began to make her presence known to the Church 200 years after her death...dormition....assumption.


#16

[quote="SmallCcatholic, post:12, topic:274549"]
Yes but that was then and this is now..I have no problem as to what He did but if he warned us about appearances in the end times and the strong deception that has and will happen..

[/quote]

I'm sorry, where did he warn us about appearances in the end times? I know of the beware of false prophets Mt 7:15.


#17

[quote="Qwikness, post:16, topic:274549"]
I'm sorry, where did he warn us about appearances in the end times? I know of the beware of false prophets Mt 7:15.

[/quote]

Here you go,,,God bless...Matthew 24:23-25:

23 At that time if anyone says to you, 'Look, here is the Christ!' or, 'There he is!' do not believe it.

24 For false Christs and false prophets will appear and perform great signs and miracles to deceive even the elect—if that were possible.

25 See, I have told you ahead of time.

There are appearances we know that will be the two witnesses..If He warned us about His appearing you would think this applies even more so for those who say they come in His name..Just an example I remember was a salt stain on a bridge.
People went crazy clogged up traffic. They had a shrine built with picture and candles
on their knees praying before a big picture of Mary..


#18

Smallc.......

Mary's voice was indeed prophetic in the early 1900's....she said most die from the sins of the flesh.

You should see the signs all around you in America....we have exchanged the altar of God for free sex.

To believe fundamentalist preachers who preach anti-Catholicism and their spins...I would say....go to another faith community...without the Church to attack, these 'preachers' would lose their ante...


#19

[quote="Hesychios, post:3, topic:274549"]
Just a quick reply.

The Roman Catholic church is not orthodox, therefore any approvals the Vatican might give to anything have no authority.

Traditionally the Orthodox take a dim view of speaking apparitions and messages from beyond, and I personally feel the same way. This would most especially be the case for something that erupts from outside the church.

[/quote]

Agreed.


#20

[quote="SmallCcatholic, post:17, topic:274549"]
Just an example I remember was a salt stain on a bridge.
People went crazy clogged up traffic. They had a shrine built with picture and candles
on their knees praying before a big picture of Mary..

[/quote]

You know these instances of Marian apparitions are highly scrutinized by Rome. There are many cases where they have not been approved. Furthermore we are not required to believe them.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.