What is the truth value of something that is uncertain of being uncertain?

What is the truth value of something that is uncertain of being uncertain?

“I’m not certain that X is uncertain.”

“I dont know if X is true or false. But I also dont know that I dont know if X is true or false.”

"One can never know that for sure, but one can never know for sure that one can never know that for sure "

These things change in the course of the passing years, but I remember studying logic at a time when there were only two truth values, T for true and F for false. If you could prove a proposition was true, it was T, and if you could prove it was false, it was F. Anything else, and it simply didn’t have a truth value at all. The concept didn’t apply.


I’m uncertain.


Assuming there are three values, true, false or uncertain, this says that X might be uncertain, but it may have already been determined that it is true or false. “I am not certain that there are 7 sacraments is uncertain.”

This is problematic. The first statement should usually be accepted as true, but the second asserts the first is false. Uncertainty is irrelevant.

Same as the second quote, but rendered universal. First it makes a presumably true statement about “that.” Then the second contradicts it by saying the first statement is uncertain, while telling us nothing about whether “that” is uncertain.

This topic was automatically closed 14 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.