Where can I find logical proofs of religious superiority?

According to the Catholic Encyclopedia (newadvent.org/cathen/01618a.htm), “the object of apologetics is to give a scientific answer to the question, Why should I be Catholic? … [And by extension,] Why should I be a Christian rather than an adherent of the Jewish religion, or the Mohammedan, or the Zoroastrian, or of some other religious system setting up a rival claim to be revealed? … [Thus,] the apologist institutes an impartial comparison of Christianity with the various rival religious systems of the world … and shows how in the person of its founder, in its moral and religious ideal and influence, the Christian religion is immeasurably superior to all others, and alone has a claim to our assent as the absolute, divinely-revealed religion.” (emphasis added)

The article itself, however, doesn’t provide any comparison. Another CE article (newadvent.org/cathen/13001a.htm) talks about criteria used to discern the authenticity of divine revelation, but only applies those criteria positively toward Christianity and not negatively toward other religions. The Catechism is the same, as far as I can tell (scborromeo.org/ccc/para/156.htm).

I know I can’t reasonably expect one person to refute every religion or cult that’s ever existed, but could anyone point me in the direction of apologetic works that show Christianity is superior to other “rival claims to be revealed?” Even more ideally, has the Vatican produced any documents which might help with this?

(And just to clarify, this isn’t a question about God’s existence, nor is it a question about Catholicism vs. Protestantism. Specifically, it’s a question about Christianity vs. other claims of divine revelation.)

I am not aware of one source that would solve it for you.

For Christianity versus atheism, I would go to CS Lewis.

For a historical account of the life of Christ, I would go to Killing Jesus by Bill O’Reilly.

For information on Peter the Apostle, I would go to Tertullian or, even better, Irenaeus of Lyons.

For a description of the origins of the Catholic Church, I would go to Ignatius of Antioch.

Additionally, The Journey Home on EWTN (you can find this on YouTube) has conversion stories from many different religions.

I might even add the Diaries of Saint Faustina.

Lastly, Islam historically has been about conquest. To me, that does not reflect God.

I hope this helps.

Christianity is the fulfillment of Judaism so the two are inextricably linked and is the only religion established by God. All other religions were established by men.

Religious superiotity? Is it a contest? The word implies dominance. All members have free will to choose. Read On the way to Jesus Christ" by Pope Benedict.

I would be cautious to read this one as a “historical account”–unless you don’t mind that O’Reilly picks and chooses which events and Jesus’ words quoted in the bible he thinks are real/truthful or not.

For example…he has said that Jesus’ last words from the Gospel of Luke–“Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do,” didn’t happen because, as he explained in a CBS interview, it was impossible for people to speak audibly while they were crucified because they don’t have enough air in their lungs to speak audibly.
And yet…he does include Jesus’ last words on the cross from the Gospel of John–“it is finished.”
Many NT and Early Christianity scholars believe this book to have several inaccuracies via O’Reilly’s own perceptions.

.

I know I can’t reasonably expect one person to refute every religion or cult that’s ever existed, but could anyone point me in the direction of apologetic works that show Christianity is superior to other “rival claims to be revealed?” Even more ideally, has the Vatican produced any documents which might help with this?

First, I would congratulate you on your perception in realizing something most Christians simply take for granted, but shouldn’t.

It is very important to understand that Divine Revelation can only be authentic in one system; considering how various and contradictory all of the systems (religions) are.

BUT, it is equally important to realize that there is no magic bullet, which will prove this religion or that one is the source of authentic Revelation for ALL people. That is simply impossible. The Church’s main document addressing that issue is called the New Testament. However, it has itself become the source of contradicting and conflicting claims and religions. Therefore, it remains for the LIVING body of the Church of Christ, the Catholic Church to answer these questions for INDIVIDUALS.

The Case For Christ
Cold Case Christianity

Two very good books at pointing out the superiority of Christianity over other religions simply by virtue of the fact that Christianity has more historical eye-witness testimony than any other religion.

There is historical proof of Christianity, and there is many eyewitnesses. Also, we need to have faith.

My question is Did anyone other than Jesus raise himself from the dead? That to me is enough proof that Catholicism is the true Faith.

Also, Jesus not only raised Himself from the dead, which he also did for Lazarus, the daughter of Jairus and the son of the widow of Naim, (who died again,) but He alone (excepting only the Virgin Mary) became impassible, glorified and eternal (in body.)

I don’t know if that concept appears in any other major religion claiming to have Divine Revelation.

This would be very difficult to do, mainly because it’s a matter of opinion.

While Christian apologists may produce works that they feel show Christianity is “superior” or better, more logical, more truthful than other religions’ claims of revelation…there are many, obviously, who don’t agree with these apologists and agree with apologists/defenders of other religions (apologists are not only within the Christian religion, and they are not only found within the religion realm).

It’s not as if people of other religions are not aware of the most effective claims of Christianity. They are aware of them, but they do not agree with/are not convinced by them.
If they did, everyone would be Christian.

So for every person who thinks an apologetic work shows Christianity’s claims to be the best…there is another who read the same work and will not.

.

I don’t agree. Even people who witnessed Jesus doing miracles still did not believe.

Well…that’s exactly what I’m saying.

One can be aware of events/words…and still not think/agree with them. A person can see another performing a “miracle” and either not define it as a miracle…or define it as a miracle, but not necessarily agree that it makes the person divine.

.

Thank you, AmbroseSJ

I think you’re asking the wrong question. Instead of “superiority”, whatever that might be, you should be asking which religion holds the Truth.

All religions, even non-Christian religions, contain some elements of truth to a certain degree. As Catholics we believe the Catholic church has the fullness of truth.

Hey all, thanks for the responses so far.

A couple people have gotten hung up on my use of the word “superiority,” and to be honest, I don’t think it was the best word to use either. However, please keep in mind that was the language used in the Catholic Encyclopedia. So when you’re criticizing that word choice, keep in mind you’re also criticizing the Catholic Encyclopedia’s word choice.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.