Working Night Shift (accidentally ate meat at 12:04 AM on Friday morning)


#1

I am working a 12 hour night shift (5 PM - 5 AM) on Thursday night into Friday morning. I started eating lunch at around 11:45 PM on Thursday and somehow while eating beef, I accidentally lost track of the time and then looked at the clock on my smartphone to see what time it is and it was 12:04 AM on Friday morning and I stopped eating the beef once I saw the time and I was like “oh no”. Would this still constitute a Mortal Sin in this case?


#2

You cannot accidentally mortally sin. It must be done with intent.

Be at peace.


#3

Be at peace…

And next time bring a tuna salad sandwich :slightly_smiling_face:
Pizza is nice too


#4

Tuna pizza perhaps.

Consider it an act of penance.


#5

In the UK it wouldn’t constitute a sin if one accidentally ate meat.

source: https://www.liturgyoffice.org.uk/Resources/Penance/Abstinence.pdf
I don’t pretend to know your local rules, however.


#7

You are being scrupulous.


#8

It was an accident. God has better things to do than play Gotcha.


#9

We really should have grown out of confessing things ‘just in case’.

It is trivialising the sacrament, and abdicating our responsibility for discerning whether or not something is a sin.

God is not a tyrant, still less devoid of commonsense, and confession is not a slot machine.


#10

Without pepperoni and sausage :angry:


#11

LOL or anchovies


#12

I’ve done this before when I worked overnights. Don’t worry! God knows your heart, and you didn’t intentionally break the friday fast from meat :slight_smile:


#13

I like anchovies. :yum:
It wouldn’t be a penance for me.


#14

Why would eating meat on Friday be a mortal sin anyway? I can see it being venial but no way mortal in my non-priestly opinion. Speak to your priest


#15

Exactly.

It is not until we get that special combination of cheese, tomato, and tuna that we can bring out the penitential inclination.

Just make sure you wash it down with some freshly juiced spinach and squash.


#16

There is no need to confess somethimg that is not a sin.


#17

Since it’s not a sin, what is there to confess? Why would the OP’s soul not be clean? And what could accidentally eating some meat lead to?


#19

Do you really think God is less merciful and loving than you? :slightly_frowning_face:


#21

For simply forgetting? At 4 minutes after midnight? Doesn’t sound to me like a God willing to die for us.


#22

OP, please be at peace. You’ve not committed any sin.

“The rules” state you cannot sin by accident. There’s nothing here to confess.


#23

He’ll punish someone for genuinely forgetting? You think God is that vengeful? It’s not like the OP decided that she was just going to scarf down a big juicy cheeseburger without any concern that abstinence was required. She was working 12 hour shift and it was midnight. How lucid would you be under those circumstances?

http://www.ewtn.com/v/experts/showmessage_print.asp?number=327418&language=en

Answer by Fr. John Trigilio on 02-15-2002:

According to Trent and the Catechism, mortal sin REQUIRES all three criteria:

  1. GRAVE MATTER 2. DELIBERATE CONSENT 3. FULL KNOWLEDGE

Since the number of days of fast and abstinence are greatly reduced, it would be a mortal sin if someone KNOWINGLY, WILLINGLY and INTENTIONALLY ate meat on a Friday of Lent or on Ash Wednesday or ate between meals or ate more than one full meal on Ash Wednesday or Good Friday. Former manuals spoke of 4 oz or more to violate the fast as a mortal sin, less than 4 oz being venial; 2 oz of meat to violate abstinence, less for venial. Today, we do not get into the number game.

If someone inadvertently, unintentionally, unknowingly eats meat on a day of abstinence or eats more than one full meal or snacks between meals on a fast day, then at most that is a VENIAL SIN.


DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in these forums do not necessarily reflect those of Catholic Answers. For official apologetics resources please visit www.catholic.com.